Skip to main content

Finding a good used car on a tight budget can be challenging. But the affordable Corolla has consistently earned top marks for quality, dependability, and safety. Here are three of the most reliable Toyota Corolla model years under $10,000.

(Note: Before purchasing any used car, obtain a vehicle history report and get a mechanical inspection.) 

2010 Toyota Corolla

The Toyota Corolla is a global favorite, selling in the millions. In fact, one in every five Toyota vehicles sold is a Corolla. This affordable car gets excellent gas mileage, offers superb value for its size, and boasts high safety ratings.

If you’re looking for a reliable used car under $10,000, consider the 2010 Toyota Corolla. J.D. Power gave the 2010 model an impressive 82/100 overall consumer rating, with 82/100 in quality and reliability and 74/100 in driving experience. This car also has excellent resale value, with a 88/100 rating.

In addition, J.D. Power ranks the Corolla as one of the top compact cars of that model year. Best of all, it’s highly affordable, with U.S. News estimating buyers are paying $6,760 to $9,095 for used 2010 models.

2011 Toyota Corolla

The 2011 Toyota Corolla is another winner, with an overall 85 consumer rating from J.D. Power. It gets high marks across the board, with an 87/100 for quality and reliability, 78/100 for driving experience, and 87/100 for resale value. 2011 Corolla owners say they like the smooth ride, trunk space, and spacious second-row seats.

The 2011 Corolla’s most notable drawback is its less-than-ideal handling on curvy roads. But its affordable price is one of the best aspects of the 2011 model. According to U.S. News, expect to pay about $8,478 and $10,056 for a used 2011 model.

2012 Toyota Corolla

The 2012 model, the newest of the most reliable Toyota Corolla years under $10,000, is a dependable, spacious compact car.

J.D. Power gave the 2012 Corolla an overall consumer score of 85/100. It also has an 88/100 in quality and reliability, 78/100 for its driving experience, and 87/100 for resale value. The 2012 model gets especially high marks from owners for its high-quality air conditioning and heating system and comfortable, well-designed interior.

This model year is a popular pick, in part due to the value it packs at an affordable price. According to U.S. News, used 2012 Toyota Corollas go for $9,804 to $10,661.


The Toyota Corolla Reigns Supreme in Only 1 State