Skip to main content

The Toyota Prius is an easily recognizable hatchback that offers versatility and comfort. In production since 1997, the Prius has become a staple for many families seeking a spacious interior and excellent safety features. The Prius is also widely credited with popularizing the hybrid electric vehicle trend that is currently going stronger than ever.

Every year, thousands of shoppers purchase new Toyota Prius models. It is also one of the hottest used cars, offering the same signature versatility and smoothness as a new model – and all at under $10,000 on average. Of course, before purchasing any used car, you should obtain a full vehicle history report and perform an inspection. This will protect you and prevent thousands of dollars in costly repairs.

1. 2010 Toyota Prius

By the 2010s, the Toyota Prius was a staple in the automotive industry, with its signature hatchback drawing the eye and remaining a top seller every year. With comfortable seating and a smooth driving experience, it’s little wonder that the Prius remains so popular. If you’re looking for a used Prius, the 2010 model year is a great option. According to J.D. Power, the 2010 Toyota Prius carries an impressive 86/100 consumer rating.

For quality and reliability, it’s also a top contender, ranking 87/100 on J.D. Power in that category and earning 81/100 for the category of driving experience. It also features 88/100 in terms of resale value, a high ranking that isn’t often granted to 2010-era used cars. Consumers who have purchased the 2010 Prius love the luxe second-row seating, ease of getting in and out of the vehicle, and smooth transmission. It can be bought for a steal as well, with U.S. News reporting that the average price for a 2010 Prius is between $7,494 and $12,430.

2. 2011 Toyota Prius

Although it earns slightly lower consumer ratings on J.D. Power, the 2011 Toyota Prius is still a force to be reckoned with. It boasts 84/100 overall consumer ranking and 86/100 for quality and reliability. It also offers a solid driving experience, earning 78/100 on J.D. Power. The resale value for the 2011 model year Prius is considered great, scoring 87/100.

The 2011 Prius has the same perks as the 2010 model, but those who have purchased this car note that the heating and air conditioning system is a particular standout. It also offers superior fuel economy and high safety scores, making it an excellent family vehicle option. However, some consumers dinged this model for its less-than-ideal handling on sharp roadways. If you’re hoping to buy your own 2011 Prius, be prepared to pay slightly more than you would for the 2010 model. U.S. News reports that this vehicle typically sells for between $9,046 and $15,742.

3. 2012 Toyota Prius

The 2012 Toyota Prius is a middle-of-the-road option for those who love the Prius, coming in at a slightly lower price than the 2011 Prius, on average, and featuring similar consumer ratings to the 2010 model. It offers plenty of cargo space and the same roomy interior as other Prius models, along with an updated exterior and interior styling for 2012.

As noted by J.D. Power, the 2012 Prius has an 85/100 overall consumer rating, along with 86/100 for quality and reliability. Regarding driving experience, the 2012 Prius comes in at 80/100, slightly higher than the 2011 model. It also earns the coveted “great” 87/100 rating for resale value.

U.S. News reports that the average price for a 2012 Toyota Prius is between $10,844 and $11,913. 

Related 4 Modern Conveniences You Can’t Miss in the 2023 Toyota Prius Prime

4 Modern Conveniences You Can’t Miss in the 2023 Toyota Prius Prime