Considering a used midsize SUV? The 2018 Toyota Highlander and 2018 Honda Pilot are popular choices providing versatility, comfort, and reliability. This comparison will examine their average used price range, fuel economy, cargo space, and powertrain specs. Additionally, it’ll touch on the Highlander’s and Pilot’s reliability scores, most common problems, and safety ratings. By evaluating these factors, we aim to provide a well-rounded analysis to help you make an informed decision.

Average used price: 2018 Honda Pilot wins

J.D. Power says people are paying $23,271 and $37,510 for a used 2018 Toyota Highlander. The 2018 Honda Pilot has a lower average used price, ranging from $19,650 to $33,077. That’s almost a $4,000 difference. However, prices may vary depending on trim level, mileage, overall condition, and location.

Powertrains: 2018 Toyota Highlander wins

Regarding powertrain specifications, the 2018 Toyota Highlander offers a range of engine options, including a 2.7-liter four-cylinder, a 3.5-liter V6, and a hybrid variant. On the other hand, the 2018 Honda Pilot has only one engine option: a 3.5-liter V6.

Fuel economy: Highlander wins

The 2018 Toyota Highlander and 2018 Honda Pilot offer solid fuel efficiency in their class. The Highlander achieves an EPA-estimated 19 mpg in the city and 24 mpg on the highway, while the 2018 Honda Pilot delivers an EPA-estimated 18 mpg in the city and 26 mpg on the highway.

However, fuel economy varies depending on driving conditions, individual driving habits, and trim level.

Cargo space: Pilot wins

The 2018 Toyota Highlander and the 2018 Honda Pilot are eight-passenger, three-row SUVs providing ample storage space. The Highlander offers a maximum of 83.7 cubic feet of cargo space, 42.3 cubic feet with the third row folded flat, and 13.8 cubic feet with all seats in use.

Meanwhile, the Pilot offers more room, with 83.9 cubic feet of maximum cargo capacity, 46.8 cubic feet behind the second row, and 16.5 cubic feet behind the third row.

Reliability scores: Highlander wins

One of the most crucial factors in a used car is reliability. According to J.D. Power, the 2018 Toyota Highlander has a reliability score of 86 out of 100, indicating “great” reliability. The 2018 Honda Pilot received a slightly lower score of 82, although it’s still considered “great” (“average” is 80 or less). These scores suggest both models offer comparable reliability, providing peace of mind for potential buyers.

But regardless of a used car’s reliability score, always obtain a vehicle history report and have a trusted mechanic perform an inspection to uncover potential problems before purchasing. 

To gain insight into potential issues, it’s worth considering common problems owners report. According to CarComplaints.com, the 2018 Toyota Highlander has a relatively low number of complaints, with the most common issues involving the transmission and infotainment system. On the other hand, owners have reported a few more 2018 Honda Pilot problems, including transmission, electrical system, and engine issues.

Safety ratings: Draw

Safety is important when choosing a family vehicle, and the 2018 Toyota Highlander and 2018 Honda Pilot earned excellent safety scores from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) and Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS).

The NHTSA gave the 2018 Highlander and 2018 Pilot five-star overall ratings. And both SUVs are IIHS Top Safety Picks.

So which used SUV is better, the 2018 Toyota Highlander or the 2018 Honda Pilot?

After comparing the 2018 Toyota Highlander and the 2018 Honda Pilot in various categories, it’s evident both models offer similar features, reliability, and safety. Ultimately, the decision between these two midsize SUVs comes down to personal preference, budget, and needs.

The only area we see a significant difference is the used purchase price. The Honda Pilot is cheaper, so it might be the better option for budget-minded shoppers. 

Though expert opinions can be valuable, it’s important to assess your priorities and test drive the vehicle to determine which suits your needs better.