2017 Toyota RAV4 vs. Honda CR-V: It All Comes Down to Preference

The Toyota RAV4 and Honda CR-V go head-to-head each year, and 2017 was no different. These 2017 two compact SUVs impressed with their comfort and versatility. But which used compact SUV would you prefer, the 2017 RAV4 or the 2017 CR-V?

Driving the 2017 Toyota RAV4

As a new model, the 2017 RAV4 stood out with its peppy power and smooth ride quality. What makes it more attractive is that Consumer Reports considers this version one of the most reliable compact SUVs you can buy. The 2017 RAV4 is part of the fourth generation that spanned from 2014 to 2018.

The 2017 RAV4 isn’t the most exciting to drive, but it’s pleasant and easy to maneuver. Base models will have a 176-hp 2.5-liter four-cylinder engine and six-speed automatic. Standard versions with front-wheel drive have an EPA rating of 26 mpg overall; those with all-wheel sacrifice fuel economy by a point. These ratings are good for the class, but it’s also worth looking at the hybrid version, which gets 32 mpg overall. 

On the inside, the RAV4 is practical and roomy. The RAV4 can seat up to five and is available with either cloth or leatherette upholstery. This Toyota offers a few connectivity features, including a touchscreen display, Bluetooth, and a CD player. Upgraded models will have more apps, such as navigation and Pandora.

Driving the 2017 Honda CR-V

RELATED: Once Upon a Toyota Crossover

The year 2017 was more profound for the CR-V. Honda completely redesigned the CR-V for this model year, and it brought some exciting changes. Like the RAV4, the CR-V is an SUV that prioritizes over performance thrills. 

There are two engines available for the 2017 CR-V. The CR-V came standard with a 184-hp, 2.4-liter four-cylinder. The upper-level trims have a turbocharged 190-hp, 1.5-liter four-cylinder. Both engines provide a similar driving experience and come with a continuously variable automatic. The base one has an EPA rating of 28 mpg overall; the turbo-four gets up to 30 mpg. Furthermore, both engines are available with FWD or AWD. 

In addition to its fuel economy, the CR-V stands outs for its refined cabin. This five-seater has many high-quality trimmings and plenty of storage space. The 2017 CR-V also offers modern infotainment features such as Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. 

2017 Toyota RAV4 problems 

A white 2016 Toyota RAV4 off-road.
Toyota RAV4 | Toyota

The 2017 RAV4 was the best-selling model in the segment. As we mentioned earlier, the 2017 RAV4 is one of the most reliable compact SUVs. There aren’t many reported trouble spots according to CR’s member data. However, according to the NHTSA, a few owners did report a few steering problems and electrical problems.

2017 Honda CR-V problems 

The 2017 Honda CR-V on display at the Frankfurt Motor Show
2017 Honda CR-V | Abdulselam Durdak/Anadolu Agency/Getty Images

RELATED: These Honda SUVs Really Do Match Their EPA Fuel-Efficiency Claim

Overall, the CR-V is a dependable car with low associated ownership costs. There are some trouble spots to be aware of, though. According to CarComplaints, the most common problem associated with the 2017 CR-V relates to its engine and high oil levels. Considering that Honda sold 378,600 CR-Vs for 2017, the complaints aren’t significant. 

Which one should you go with?

CR’s data shows that the average cost for a 2017 RAV4 falls between $17,525 – $24,350. The average cost for a 2017 CR-V ranges between $18,075 – $24,725. Both options are practical and enjoyable. We’d say that the CR-V is the better option if you want more modern infotainment and safety features. But for a simpler experience, you’ll probably want the RAV4.