2017 Honda Accord vs. 2017 Toyota Camry: Which Used Midsize Sedan Wins?
The 2017 Honda Accord and 2017 Toyota Camry are excellent used cars. They boast reliability, fuel efficiency, and a host of features. Let’s compare these two midsize sedans in various categories, including average used price, gas mileage, reliability scores, and common problems. By examining these factors, we can determine whether a used Accord or Camry might be better for prospective buyers.
2017 Honda Accord vs. 2017 Toyota Camry: Price and fuel economy
According to J.D. Power, the 2017 Honda Accord has an average used price range of $15,466 to $22,939. The market research firm scores this model year’s resale value as 83 out of 100, which is in the “great” range for a used car.
J.D. Power reports that the 2017 Toyota Camry has a similar average used price range of $16,388 to $22,577. Prices may vary based on factors such as mileage, trim level, and condition. The resale value of the 2017 Accord is 79 out of 100, which is considered “average.”
As for gas mileage, the 2017 Accord and 2017 Camry offer competitive numbers, but the Accord is slightly more fuel efficient. The 2017 Accord’s base four-cylinder engine achieves an EPA-estimated 23 mpg in the city and 32 mpg on the highway.
On the other hand, the 2017 Camry’s base four-cylinder delivers an EPA-estimated 21 mpg in the city and 30 mpg on the highway.
These figures will vary depending on other engine options and driving conditions.
2017 Honda Accord vs. 2017 Toyota Camry: Reliability, common problems, and safety
Reliability is an essential aspect to consider when purchasing a used vehicle. According to J.D. Power’s reliability ratings, the 2017 Accord receives a “great” score of 82 out of 100, indicating a solid track record for dependability. But the 2017 Camry is even more reliable, earning an 86 out of 100.
Analyzing owner-reported problems reported on CarComplaints.com, we see the 2017 Accord has had a few complaints. Some drivers have reported issues with the interior accessories, electrical system, and transmission. But overall, the 2017 Honda Accord maintains a positive reputation for reliability.
CarComplaints.com reports that the 2017 Camry also demonstrates good reliability, with few significant complaints reported. However, some owners have noted concerns about the power accessories and brakes.
Other factors that can be considered in the comparison include safety ratings. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) awarded the 2017 Accord and the 2017 Camry five-star overall safety ratings. And both earned Top Safety Pick+ honors from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS).
Which used midsize sedan is better?
The 2017 Accord and 2017 Camry are reliable, fuel-efficient sedans with excellent safety ratings. The 2017 Accord has a slightly lower used price. However, reliability might be a concern with the 2017 Accord because it has received far more complaints than the 2017 Camry.
Based on the available data, declaring one model as the better pick isn’t easy. However, considering the 2017 Accord’s slightly lower average used price range, it might be a more favorable choice for budget-conscious buyers. But considering owner complaints, the 2017 Camry comes out as the winner. All other factors being equal, the fun-to-drive 2017 Camry might be the better pick.
Ultimately, personal preferences, individual needs, and thorough test drives should guide decision-making. Factors such as accident history, mileage, and the history of the car’s maintenance should be considered when determining which vehicle to choose.
Also, regardless of a used car’s reliability score, always obtain a vehicle history report and have a trusted mechanic perform an inspection to uncover potential problems before purchasing.
