Skip to main content

Let’s see if the Chevrolet Colorado and Toyota Tacoma live up to their reputations. You might think that one truck is more reliable than the other, but we’re here to find the truth. Let’s see how reliable the 2023 Chevy Colorado is compared to the 2023 Toyota Tacoma.

2023 Chevy Colorado vs. 2023 Toyota Tacoma: Which truck is more reliable? 

The 2023 Toyota Tacoma climning over rocks
2023 Toyota Tacoma | Toyota

The 2023 Chevy Colorado and 2023 Toyota Tacoma might be full of surprises. Traditionally, the Chevy Colorado doesn’t have the best reputation for being a dependable option. But the Toyota Tacoma is seen as something that can last forever. 

It might be time for reputations to change in this new day and age. The 2023 Colorado has a score of 85 out of 100, according to J.D.Power. This is great because anything between 81 to 90 is above-average. Scores between 91 to 100 are best. 

J.D.Power gave the 2023 Tacoma a score of 83 out of 100. This means that it’s also above average, and it’s only two points behind the Colorado. 

But this ranking also considers the quality, and the Colorado just launched a new generation, while the Tacoma has been pretty much the same since 2016. The 2023 Tacoma still has drum brakes! 

You can expect the average Colorado model to reach between 200,000 to 300,000 miles. It should reach 200,000 miles before needing a severe repair. If you drive about 15,000 miles per year, you can receive between 16 to 20 years of service on the road. 

The average Tacoma model has no problem surpassing 200,000 miles and can easily make it past 300,000 miles. There are some Tacoma models that have made it over 400,000 miles and keep on going. But proper care and regular maintenance are keys to success.

It can reach 300,000 miles before severe problems strike and can provide 20 to 25 years of service on the road. So, the Tacoma gets the crown in terms of longevity. Despite being ranked two points behind the Colorado, the Tacoma has a better reputation for reliability.

Is the Colorado stronger than the Tacoma? 

The 2023 Chevy Colorado packs extra muscle against the 2023 Toyota Tacoma. The standard turbocharged 2.7-liter four-cylinder engine provides 237 hp and 260 lb-ft of torque. 

The 2.7 Turbo Plus variant cranks out 310 hp and 391 lb-ft of torque. The Turbo High-Output option boosts the torque to 437 hp. 

With the standard Tacoma, the 2.7-liter four-cylinder engine has 159 hp and 180 lb-ft of torque. Upgrade to the 3.5-liter V6 engine for 278 hp and 265 lb-ft of torque. The 2024 Tacoma has more power, and the 2024 Colorado is primarily a carry over model.

When properly equipped, the Colorado can tow up to 7,700 lbs and can carry a payload of up to 1,684 lbs. The Tacoma can tow up to 6,800 lbs and can carry a payload of up to 1,685 lbs. 

Does the Tacoma or Colorado have a better resale value? 

The 2023 Chevy Colorado in rocky terrain
2023 Chevy Colorado | Chevrolet

J.D.Power gave the 2023 Toyota Tacoma a score of 95 out of 100 for its resale value, and the 2023 Chevy Colorado rings in with a score of 89. With these scores, a higher ranking equals a lower depreciation rate. 

The Tacoma actually has the class-leading resale value, making it tough to compete against. This is wild because the 2023 Colorado has more modern tech and standard features. But it also has a higher price, so the Tacoma may offer more value. 

Also, the Tacoma leads the segment in sales. More people buy the Tacoma than the Colorado, which should lead to more used Tacoma models on the market. With more trucks available, prices should come down. However, the demand for new and used Tacoma trucks still runs rampant.

Things could change as the brand-new 2024 Tacoma emerges. The new frame and engine lineup might cause prices to rise and its reliability ranking to drop. However, the Colorado can still tow more than the new Tacoma.