Best Used Toyota Tundra Model Years According to Consumer Reports

This truck was once called the “Camry of pickup trucks,” according to Consumer Reports. The Toyota Tundra is one of the best pickup trucks on American soil. Its reputation for reliability is that of legend. However, Toyota’s history for building a reliable machine doesn’t stop at the Camry and the Corolla.

A Toyota Tundra truck on display at an auto show
A white Toyota Tundra | SAUL LOEB/AFP via Getty Images

The Toyota Tundra and the Toyota Tacoma are pickup trucks that evoke feelings of trust in consumers. In a best used vehicles for various budgets article from Consumer Reports, the only trucks on the list are various years of the Toyota Tundra. So, from that information, we can reasonably assume that these are the best used Toyota Tundra model years according to Consumer Reports.

2010-2012 Toyota Tundra pickup truck

The article by Consumer Reports, highlights used cars, trucks, and SUVs for different budgets. The Toyota Tundra pickup truck is shown as the best used truck for the $10,000-$15,000 budget. For this price, CR recommends the 2010-2012 Tundra. So, according to CR, these are the best used Toyota Tundra model years for a price range of $10-$12 grand.

“Among full-sized pickups, the Tundra is a reliable option. There’s plenty of power from the V8 engine, off-road prowess and towing capability are impressive, and fuel economy is competitive. The damped tailgate is a nice convenience feature.”

Consumer Reports

CR data shows that the last redesign year for the Toyota Tundra was 2007. This means that you can go back as far as 10 model years and still find yourself in a truck fundamentally the same as the current version. Though there have been tweaks throughout the year, the 2010-2012 Tundra can be bought for less than half the price of a new Toyota Tundra pickup truck.

The 2011 Toyota Tundra , like this one that's parked on a dirt road, is one of the best Used Toyota Tundra model years according to Consumer Reports
2011 Toyota Tundra | Toyota

2013-2015 model year

These are the best used Toyota Tundra model years for a budget between $15,000 and $20,000–according to Consumer Reports. Ratings for these model years show perfect predicted reliability scores. The 2013, 2014, and 2015 are all found for this price point.

These are reliable pickup trucks recommended by CR. They are also loved by consumers. In terms of owner satisfaction, all three of these Toyota Tundra Pickup trucks earned a 4 out of 5 rating.

A Toyota Tundra TRD Pro on display at an auto show, a great example pf a Consumer Reports favorite
Toyota Tundra TRD Pro | Raymond Boyd/Getty Images

The 2016 Tundra

For between $20,000 and $25,000, the 2016 Tundra is the recommended. It’s among the best Used Toyota Tundra model years because it’s recent enough to offer more modern tech than some of the older years. CR writes that “easily the Tundra’s best attribute is its 5.7-liter V8, which produces effortless power and a still-competitive 15 mpg.” The review also goes on to claim that “the Tundra is also the most reliable full-sized truck on the market.”

2016 Toyota Tundra is on display at the 108th Annual Chicago Auto Show at McCormick Place
The Toyota Tundra | Raymond Boyd/Getty Images

This is probably why it makes such a good used truck. Additionally, the Tundra from the 2016 model year gets a 4 out of 5 for both owner satisfaction and reliability. However, CR does warn that the Tundra can feel bit more rugged in terms of driving experience. At least it does when its compared to other modern pickup trucks. A loud cabin and unrefined handle can bring it down a notch. Still, its predicted reliability speaks for itself.

A Toyota Tundra from 2018

The last truck that Consumer Reports recommends for these various budget ranges is the 2018 Tundra. This is one of the best used Toyota Tundra model years if you have a $25,000-$30,000 budget. Furthermore, this year Toyota truck is another one that received a coveted perfect predicted reliability score from CR.


The Legendary Ford F-250 Powerstroke Is a Good Used Diesel Pickup Truck

The 2018 model Tundra pickup truck received the Toyota safety suite for the first time in the truck’s history. It’s rough, gritty and ready to work. However, we should still note that the 2018 Toyota Tundra is still considered unrefined. It’s no luxury truck. But it does get the job done. CR recommends this Tundra as a good used pickup truck.