Why Consumer Reports Says You Might Want the F-150 Over the Silverado 1500

It’s a meme-worthy rivalry that’s plagued family dinner tables for years. Which truck is better, Ford or Chevrolet? Well, Consumer Reports took a closer look at the F-150 and Silverado 1500 for the ultimate faceoff. We’ll highlight which truck wins out and discuss just how different these competitors really are.

Big differences between the F-150 and Silverado 1500

This faceoff features a host of apples-to-apples reviews of basic performance, safety, convenience, comfort, and technology. Both the F-150 and Silverado 1500 boast a healthy contribution in all categories. But, there can be only one victor.

Both trucks seem to get the job done. It’s often a neck-and-neck competition for first and second place between the two. However, there’s something to be said for differentiating from the pack, as each truck ventures to improve in completely different aspects.

Consumer preference and personal taste play significant roles in each truck. Style, configuration, and amenities can drastically vary between the models. This sometimes means one truck can best the other in some categories, but not others.

It’s not uncommon to see contradictory reviews out there as a result. The fresh Silverado 1500 design can be more attractive to buyers, for example. Those interested in a classic look may favor the F-150, which continues its beloved style since 2015.

Silverado offered its praiseworthy four-cylinder engine in 2019 to change things up, too. This is still up for debate as an improvement for some Chevy enthusiasts.

Standard versus available safety options

In comparing these rival trucks, it’s important to note the difference between what comes standard and what is considered available in terms of safety. Standard safety on the Silverado 1500 only features Teen Driver and rearview camera. But the following safety features come standard with the F-150:

  • Automatic emergency braking
  • Pedestrian detection
  • Auto high beams
  • Rearview camera with Dynamic Hitch Assist

These are the available safety options for the Ford F-150:

  • Lane Keep Assist
  • Blind Spot Monitoring
  • Rear Cross-Traffic Alert
  • Active Park Assist
  • 360-degree camera system
  • Rear parking sensors
  • Adaptive cruise control

Here are the Silverado 1500’s available safety options:

  • Lane keep assist
  • Rear cross-traffic alert
  • Blind-spot monitoring
  • Low-speed forward automatic braking
  • Front pedestrian braking
  • Heads-up display
  • Surround-view parking camera
  • Front and rear parking sensors

What the Chevy Silverado 1500 does better

With the 2019 redesign, Silverado opted for a little more size, a little less weight, and softer edges. Its boxes can hold more cargo than the F-150 with added attention to engineering.

It offers a host of configuration options too, making customizing a Silverado ideal. Some consumers say that the 5.3-liter engine maneuvers like a car, with amazing agility.

The F-150 has bragging rights, too

Ford consistently outsells Chevy and continues to be America’s best-selling truck overall. In Consumer Reports review, the F-150 has other bragging rights, too.

Interior comfort and reduced cabin noise equal a win for Ford. With Silverado’s cheap-feeling seats, it’s a lot more comfortable to settle into the F-150’s helm behind the wheel. Also, in terms of safety ratings, no truck in its class can compete with Ford’s five-star crash-test rating.

So, which truck wins this Consumer Reports faceoff?

It may not have changed its look for a while, but the Ford F-150 comes out ahead of Silverado 1500. Despite Chevy’s redesign and increased cargo capacity, it doesn’t measure up overall. Seat and interior comfort, along with special attention to safety features, have earned the F-150’s place as the champion.

Ford F-150 fans, you now have some material for the ongoing debate with your Chevy-loving friends and family. At least in this Consumer Reports evaluation, the F-150 is not only the best-selling truck, but it’s also considered better than Silverado 1500.