The Toyota Tacoma, famous for its its durability, off-road capabilities, and convenience, first hit U.S. roads in 1995. Born a compact truck, the Tacoma ultimately became a go-to for drivers seeking a reliable, midsize truck, with models like the SR5 becoming popular for their classic appeal and strong performance. However, not all model years achieved high marks for reliability and owner satisfaction. Some were plagued by issues ranging from engine and transmission failures to excessive rust, impacting their resale value and usability. Below is a list of seven Toyota Tacoma model years to avoid if you’re considering buying used. These years had lower reliability ratings, widespread complaints, or significant recalls, making them less desirable.

2005 Toyota Tacoma

The 2005 Tacoma, the first model year of the second generation, is frequently reported for rust-related issues, especially with the frame. Numerous owners experienced frame corrosion that compromised the truck’s safety. Toyota eventually issued a recall and offered frame replacements for severely rusted models, but the problem still haunts the 2005 models. According to CarComplaints.com, this model year ranks as one of the most problematic due to the rust issue and a lack of timely intervention by Toyota to address these concerns.

2006 Toyota Tacoma

Continuing with the second-generation Tacoma, the 2006 model suffers from issues similar to the 2005, with complaints of excessive rust on the frame and suspension components. In addition to rust, this model year also had issues with the truck’s clutch, which could prematurely wear down. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) also received reports of unintended acceleration, though these were less frequent. If you’re eyeing a 2006 Tacoma, be cautious of potential frame corrosion, even if it’s been treated or repaired.

2012 Toyota Tacoma

The 2012 Tacoma saw an increase in complaints about its engine performance and electronic stability control system, with many drivers reporting sudden stalling and engine hesitation. The transmission in this model is also known to experience “hard shifting” between gears, which can be uncomfortable and even unsafe, particularly at highway speeds. According to CarComplaints.com, 2012 models experienced a spike in user complaints related to reliability, and these issues were significant enough to deter some potential buyers from considering this year’s model.

2014 Toyota Tacoma

While the 2014 Tacoma is generally reliable, it’s not without its issues. Some drivers experienced engine-related problems, specifically with the truck’s throttle body, which can lead to sudden and unresponsive acceleration. Another common issue involves the leaf springs, which can break under heavy load, impacting the suspension. Although Toyota issued a recall for the faulty leaf springs, the repair did not address all related suspension problems. These issues led to its placement on our list of Toyota Tacoma years to avoid.

2015 Toyota Tacoma

The 2015 Tacoma, despite being the last year of the second generation, saw a spike in complaints about transmission failures and faulty drivetrain components. Complaints centered around delayed transmission response and harsh shifting. While the engine is otherwise dependable, these transmission issues significantly reduce the truck’s appeal among used buyers.

2016 Toyota Tacoma

As the first model year of the third generation, the 2016 Tacoma introduced a new design, but it also came with significant issues. Many drivers reported problems with the transmission, including delayed shifting and a tendency to “hunt” for the correct gear, which can make driving feel less smooth. According to the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), some safety features were also not as refined in this model year, which further reduced its desirability among buyers looking for reliability and driver-assist features​.​

2017 Toyota Tacoma

Continuing with the third generation, the 2017 Tacoma faced complaints about transmission and engine issues, including difficulty shifting and a lack of power under load. Drivers on CarComplaints.com reported that the transmission could be sluggish, particularly at lower speeds, which can impact the truck’s performance both on- and off-road. Additionally, this model year saw a significant number of electrical issues, including malfunctioning backup cameras and intermittent connectivity in the infotainment system. Due to these recurring issues, the 2017 Tacoma holds lower-than-average satisfaction ratings among used truck buyers​.​

If you’re looking for a used Tacoma, be sure to check out MotorBiscuit’s seamless car buying tool to compare listings in your area and find the best deal near you.

While the Tacoma is often a reliable choice for those seeking a midsize truck, these specific years have shown a tendency for significant issues, from frame rust to transmission troubles. You might stay away from our list of Toyota Tacoma years to avoid to minimize the risk of unexpected repairs. Instead, consider later third-generation models (from 2018 onward) or earlier, well-maintained models outside of the problematic years. With a careful selection, you can still find a durable Tacoma that fits your needs without these common pitfalls.