The Only Used Trucks Consumer Reports Recommends Are Toyotas and Hondas

If you’re in the market for a good used truck, you’ll likely find a wide selection to choose from. Today’s market offers trucks of all sizes with varying capabilities. These days, tucks are often used as family vehicles and offer lots of creature comforts and safety features. 

Once you’ve determined what you need in a truck, then you find a truck known for customer satisfaction, reliability, and value. The good news? Consumer Reports has already done a lot of the research for you. Consumer Reports recommends used trucks with above-average reliability, strong safety test results, and strong customer satisfaction ratings.

A search for recommended used pickup trucks on Consumer Reports reveals just two trucks: Honda Ridgeline and Toyota Tundra.

What makes the Honda Ridgeline a great used truck?

Consumer Reports recommends Honda Ridgeline models from 2006 through 2014. The first generation of Ridgeline challenged traditional pickup trucks of the time.

They ranked it as the best compact truck they ever tested. A beefier version of the platform used for the Honda Pilot, the Honda Ridgeline offers a smooth ride with agile handling. It doesn’t feel like driving a cumbersome truck.

The Ridgeline offers a tailgate that you can open horizontally or vertically. There’s a lockable trunk under the bed and its weatherproof for even greater convenience. They offer capable powertrains but kept the noise down. From 2009, they added more torque though the ride got a little louder.

These Ridgeline models don’t have telescoping steering wheels and the five-foot cargo bed is a little short for some. But the bed doesn’t have wheel arch intrusions and the bed is made from composite plastic.

The Ridgeline wasn’t designed for off-roading but it can handle such adventures competently. It can tow up to 5,000 pounds and offers a payload of 1,500 pounds. 

The Toyota Tundra is always reliable

RELATED: 5 Reasons the Toyota Tundra Is Better Than the Ford F-150

Consumer Reports recommends a wide range of Toyota Tundras from 2000 to 2006, 2007 to 2008, 2010 to 2016 and 2018 to 2019. 

The first generation of Toyota Tundra from 2000 to 2006 offers exceptional value for a used truck according to Consumer Reports. They found they handle well with smooth powertrains.

It offers a comfortable, capable ride, and stability control was added as an option in 2004. With strong hauling and towing capabilities and strong IIHS test results behind them, the early Tundras are strong performers. 

The second generation from 2007 to 2019 also offers several excellent Tundra models. Built in Texas, these models were beefed up to compete with their 1/2 ton peers and their hauling and towing numbers were dialed up. 

It offers three bed lengths and three cab sizes with more powertrain options. These Tundras are impressive when it comes to off-roading and handle well for big trucks.

The second generation got tilt-and-telescoping steering columns and a quiet, capable ride. The second generation got tilt-and-telescoping steering columns and a quiet, capable ride.

A reputation for reliability

RELATED: Best Used Pickup Trucks

One thing both the Honda Ridgeline and the Toyota Tundra have in common? Consistently strong predicted reliability ratings.

Each year, Consumer Reports gathers detailed data from its members to create elaborate ‘Reliability Histories’ for literally hundreds of vehicles. These histories cover models available on the market from 2000 to the latest year.

Scoring each model on 17 different areas, the predicted reliability charts on the site show you whether the model has had fewer or more problems than the average model that year.

It is invaluable information for those shopping for used vehicles. Their overall reliability scores provide a summary that makes it easy to make quick comparisons. These scores help consumers know which vehicles to consider and which to pass on.

Both the Honda Ridgeline and Toyota Tundra have consistently earned high makes in reliability reports over the years. Both trucks live up to their reputations as dependable, competent trucks that can get the job done without constantly requiring expensive repairs.