Tesla is constantly under the regulatory microscope, but the electric automaker just dodged a massive bullet. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration officially shot down a sweeping petition that sought to force a recall of roughly 2.26 million Tesla vehicles. The complaint alleged that the brand’s control layout was inherently dangerous and prone to causing unintended acceleration, but the government’s data tells a completely different story.
The One-Pedal Driving Myth
This started back in March of 2023 when a petition demanded that the government recall essentially every single Tesla produced since 2013. The argument revolved around Tesla’s heavy reliance on regenerative braking – often referred to as “one-pedal driving”. This was apparently confusing owners.
The petitioners claimed this layout drastically increased the risk of “pedal misapplication,” causing drivers to accidentally stomp the accelerator when they actually meant to hit the brakes.
To fix this alleged flaw, the petition wanted NHTSA to force Tesla to implement new software safeguards, like requiring drivers to physically tap the brake pedal before the vehicle could come to a complete stop.
However, after reviewing the telemetry and crash data, federal safety regulators bluntly rejected the request. According to NHTSA, there is absolutely no evidence pointing to a design defect. In the handful of crashes reviewed, the vehicle logs showed that the cars responded exactly as commanded. In other words: it was simply driver error. The agency also pointed out that one-pedal driving is an industry-wide standard for modern electric vehicles, not a unique Tesla quirk.
Read More from MotorBiscuit:
FSD Is Still in the Hot Seat
While clearing the pedal-confusion hurdle is a major win for Elon Musk’s company, the regulatory storm is far from over. On Thursday, NHTSA actively escalated a separate, ongoing investigation into Tesla’s highly controversial Full Self-Driving software.
The feds are currently scrutinizing over 3 million FSD-equipped vehicles following concerns that the advanced driver-assistance system struggles to function properly in low-visibility situations, such as dense fog, blinding sun glare, or heavy rain. The probe has now been officially upgraded to an “engineering analysis.” In the regulatory world, this is the final, required investigative hurdle the agency must clear before it can legally demand a mandatory recall.
Despite the intense scrutiny in the United States, Tesla might be on the verge of a massive breakthrough across the Atlantic. The automaker recently indicated that the Dutch vehicle authority is currently evaluating its FSD software suite.
If everything goes according to plan, Tesla expects the Netherlands to officially green-light the technology by mid-April. Landing that localized approval could act as the first domino to fall, potentially paving the way for full, EU-wide regulatory clearance for FSD by the summer.
