Study: Most Reliable 2021 Pickup Trucks That’ll Last Over 200,000 Miles

If you’ve looked into getting a brand-new truck recently, then you’ll know that most new offerings are far from affordable. As a result, you’ll want to make sure to protect your investment by picking the best model. To help out, we’ll be looking at the most reliable 2021 pickup trucks that should surpass 200,000 miles.

iSeeCars compiled this study by looking at over 11.8 million used trucks sold, noting which models surpassed 200,000 most often. With this data, iSeeCars then created its reliability score, picking out the most reliable models you should look out for. However, it is worth pointing out that some of these models offer various powertrain options, which aren’t all equally as reliable.

Most reliable 2021 full-size pickup trucks

An image of a Toyota Tundra outdoors.
Toyota Tundra | Toyota

Let’s start this list of the most reliable pickup trucks with some of the most popular full-size options. It won’t surprise you to learn that the Toyota Tundra landed at the top of this list. According to iSeeCars, this full-size truck received an 8/10 reliability score. While its 5.7-liter V8 remains largely unchanged since its debut in 2007, iSeeCars found that this powertrain’s simplicity lends to long-term durability.

iSeeCars estimates that you’ll pay between $38,470 to $56,920 for a brand-new example, while a three-year-old one will cost between $29,998 to $46,660. Additionally, this truck can tow up to 10,200 lb.

Next up, we’ve got the Chevy Silverado 1500 with a 7.3/10 reliability rating. According to iSeeCars, the benefit of this model is that it offers plenty of engine and transmission options. However, if you plan to use it to move around heavy loads, iSeeCars recommends sticking to the V8 or turbocharged variants. On average, expect to pay $32,730 to $58,970 for a new one versus $27,189 to $43,406 for a three-year-old example, says iSeeCars.

The Ford F-150 is next in this list of most reliable pickup trucks with a 6.7/10 reliability rating, says iSeeCars. Part of what makes this particular model interesting is the fact that it offers a hybrid engine that can tow up to 14,000 pounds. As a result, it has the highest towing capacity in its class. According to iSeeCars, a brand-new F-150 should cost you between $32,986 to $68,973 while a three-year-old one is $26,999 to $52,893.

Most reliable 2021 mid-size pickup trucks

An image of a Toyota Tacoma, one of the most reliable mid-size pickup trucks.
Toyota Tacoma | Toyota

Within this list of most reliable pickup trucks, there are just two midsize options. The first is the Toyota Tacoma and its 8/10 reliability rating, matching the larger Tundra. Like its larger sibling, a simple powertrain results in long-term reliability. This reliable Toyota has a maximum towing rating of 6,800 lb. According to iSeeCars, you should pay between $28,173 to $45,412 for a new one, while a three-year-old example should cost between $24,689 to $38,995.

Despite its controversial standing in the pickup truck world, the Honda Ridgeline has more than proved itself as an ultra-reliable model. According to iSeeCars, this truck gets an 8.2/10 reliability rating, making it the most reliable on this list. While its max 5,000-lb towing rating is less than some competitors, its on-road comfort is hard to beat. iSeeCars estimates a new one will cost you between $34,611 to $44,619, while a three-year-old example should cost between $25,995 to $36,069.

Most reliable 2021 heavy-duty options

An image of a Ram 3500 Heavy Duty parked outdoors.
2021 Ram 3500 Heavy Duty | Stellantis

Should the $67,500 Rivian R1T Be Your First Electric Pickup Truck?

In case you need extra power, here are iSeeCars’ most reliable heavy-duty pickup trucks. The top pick is the Ram 3500. Unfortunately, these heavy-duty examples don’t have reliability ratings and are simply determined by their propensity to surpass 200,000 miles. With up to 1075 lb-ft, iSeeCars estimates that this truck can tow up to 37,000 lb.

Lastly, we’ve got the Chevy Silverado 2500HD. Like the ram, this model’s capabilities far exceed those of a full-size truck. According to Chevy, this heavy-duty model can tow up to 14,000 lb.

Regardless of which segment you’re buying in, now you’ll be able to ensure your hard-earned dollars go into a truck that will stand the test of time.