10 Most Satisfying Vehicles in the Midwest According to Consumer Reports

Certain popular cars in some regions of the U.S. might be largely ignored in others. Sometimes this comes down to a matter of utility. If a region sees all four seasons, you need a car equipped to handle any weather. People are always looking for the most satisfying vehicles.

Consumers can also be drawn to the car’s performance, aesthetics, or anything else. Consumer Reports has the latest info on the Midwest’s favorites.

1. Tesla Model Y is a satisfying vehicle

The Model Y is actually considered one of the best cars in all four regions of the United States. Despite being bigger than the Model 3, its handling is still equally as athletic.

Unfortunately, it also shares the Model 3’s harsh ride quality. On the plus side, Consumer Reports says that the Model Y’s rear row is more accommodating for adults.

2. Toyota Sienna

Families will love this minivan because it can seat up to eight riders and has plenty of interior storage space. As you’d expect of such a hulking vehicle, it needs extra time to brake and doesn’t have impressive handling skills. Even so, its ride is smooth, and its hybrid powertrain easily gets 36 mpg combined.

3. Tesla Model 3

A row of white Tesla Model 3 vehicles lined up, also known as one of the. most satisfying vehicles in the midwest.
Tesla Model 3 | Getty Images

The Tesla Model 3 has a high owner satisfaction rating on Consumer Reports, mainly because it’s so enjoyable to drive. The Long Range model has a dual-motor setup with AWD, 334 miles of range, and the power to reach 60 mph in 4.2 seconds.

Of course, not everyone is a fan of the Model 3’s vague blind-spot monitoring system and the overabundance of touch-operated features. Consumer Reports also says the suspension is unforgiving, so driving on relatively smooth roads is better.

4. Honda Ridgeline

The Honda Ridgeline is one of the most reliable trucks you can buy, partially because of its unibody construction. It also impresses consumers with its plush ride and surprisingly decent fuel economy rating of 21 mpg combined. Towing capacity is a little disappointing, but this truck’s composite bed can hold up to 1,583 pounds.

5. BMW X5 is a satisfying vehicle

This midsize SUV is pricey, but Consumer Reports says it’s one of the best in the segment. It offers a pleasing lineup of three turbocharged engines, one of which is found inside a plug-in hybrid. 

Each one offers smooth performance, a comfortable ride, and quiet operations. The X5’s interior looks stylish and pristine all around.

6. Kia Telluride 

The Telluride’s consistent praise from both owners and critics is well-deserved. It’s a popular family vehicle due to its extensive library of safety features and ample interior dimensions. It’s also quite capable. It can tow up to 5,000 pounds with the option of AWD.

7. Ford Mustang

The Ford Mustang might not have AWD, but it does have a special drive mode for wet or snowy surfaces. Consumer Reports enjoyed driving the GT trim the most, praising its addictive engine note and quick acceleration. Despite its sporty nature, Consumer Reports was pleasantly surprised that the Ford Mustang’s ride wasn’t too firm.

8. Volkswagen Jetta

The Jetta shines the most in terms of gas mileage, rated for up to 31 mpg in the city and 41 mpg on the highway. Consumer Reports complains that the car’s handling could use some work, but its ride quality is solid. The Volkswagen Jetta is also roomy inside and features intuitive technology controls.

9. Ford F-150

This pickup truck isn’t just beloved for its impressive hauling and towing capabilities. The Ford F-150 also has agreeable handling, spacious crew cabs, and efficient powertrain options. Those looking for off-roading fun will likely be very satisfied with the Raptor trim’s abilities.

10. Subaru Legacy is a satisfying vehicle


The Most Satisfying SUVs in the South According to Owners

Consumer Reports says that the Subaru Legacy’s ride quality is just as quiet and smooth as a midsize luxury car. Despite its standard AWD powertrain, the Legacy is also renowned for its great mileage (30 mpg combined per the EPA).