The Most Reliable 5-Year-Old Used Midsize SUVs According to Consumer Reports

Midsize SUVs are popular for a reason. They give you a commanding view of the road, are often available with all-wheel drive, and offer up more than enough space for passengers and cargo alike. The bad news, however, is that buying a new midsize SUV can cost a pretty penny. The good news is that buying a used midsize SUV makes for an excellent solution, especially if you opt for one of the most reliable five-year-old used midsize SUVs. 

The 2016 Lexus GX is a reliable used midsize SUV

Average Price: $34,225 – $36,175
Reliability Rating: 5/5

If you’re buying a used midsize SUV, chances are you want one that’s known for being reliable. Fortunately, the 2016 Lexus GX is just that. In fact, Consumer Reports highlighted the 2016 Lexus GX as one of the most reliable five-year-old used midsize SUVs. The organization even gave it a five out of five reliability rating.

The 2016 Lexus GX has more going for it than its reliability ratings too. According to Consumer Reports, this luxury SUV delivers impressive off-road performance. Inside, the used midsize SUV provides a commanding view of the road. Its seats are also very comfortable. However, its third-row can be challenging to get in and out of, Consumer Reports added.

The 2016 Toyota Highlander is a used SUV that’s also reliable

Average Price: $22,275 – $29,850
Reliability Rating: 5/5

The 2016 Lexus GS isn’t the only reliable used midsize SUV worth your consideration. Consumer Reports also tapped the 2016 Toyota Highlander as one of the most reliable five-year-old used midsize SUVs. Though, that shouldn’t come as too much of a surprise. In fact, according to Consumer Reports, the Toyota Highlander has a reputation for “impeccable reliability.”

What’s even more appealing is the 2016 Toyota Highlander’s owner satisfaction rating. The organization gave the used Toyota Highlander SUV a four out of five owner satisfaction rating. Consumer Reports’ data shows that Highlander owners were most satisfied with the used Toyota SUV’s driving experience, comfort, and styling.

The 2016 Mercedes-Benz GLE is a used luxury SUV

Average Price: $27,500 – $60,500
Reliability Rating: 5/5 

The 2016 Mercedes-Benz GLE is a used luxury SUV with plenty to offer. It comes driven by a V6 engine that “serves up smooth and powerful acceleration.” Handling is responsive too. It can also tow a maximum of 7,200 pounds when properly equipped. And when it comes to its interior? The 2016 Mercedes-Benz GLE benefits from an upgraded infotainment system.

Perhaps what’s most appealing about the 2016 Mercedes-Benz GLE, however, is its reliability ratings. Consumer Reports gave it a five out of five reliability rating, making it one of the most reliable five-year-old used midsize SUVs on the road today. 

The 2016 Lexus RX delivers “superb reliability”

Average Price: $29,975 – $35,300
Reliability Rating: 5/5

For a five-year-old used midsize SUV that boasts “superb reliability,” consider the 2016 Lexus RS. The 2016 Lexus RS is not only recommended by Consumer Reports, but the organization also gave it a five out of five reliability rating. Such a high reliability rating isn’t all that unusual for the Lexus RX SUV, either. 

Consumer Reports isn’t the only one that recommends the 2016 Lexus RX either. As it turns out, Kelley Blue Book also found itself enamored with the used Lexus RX. “If you want a 2-row, 5-passenger luxury SUV that emphasizes serene driving characteristics and has a cabin that coddles, it’s hard to beat the Lexus RX,” Kelley Blue Book said in its review of the used midsize SUV.

The 2016 Toyota 4Runner has a reputation for reliability

A red 2016 Toyota 4Runner parked at dusk, the 2016 Toyota 4Runner is one of the most reliable 5-year-old used midsize SUVs
2016 Toyota 4Runner | Toyota

Average Price: $26,350 – $37,200
Reliability Rating: 5/5

If you’re in the market for a used midsize SUV, it’s hard to beat the Toyota 4Runner. That sentiment is especially true if you’re shopping for the most reliable five-year-old used midsize SUV. Consumer Reports not only gave the 2016 Toyota 4Runner a five out of five reliability rating but also recommends the used midsize SUV.

The used Toyota 4Runner doesn’t just have a reputation for being a reliable midsize SUV either. This body-on-frame SUV also has a storied history as a capable off-roader. As a matter of fact, according to Consumer Reports, off-road is where the used 4Runner excels. It boasts plenty of ground clearance, comes standard with underbody skid plates, and features a part-time four-wheel-drive system.

The 2016 Nissan Murano reliability ratings aim to impress

Average Price: $17,150 – $24,425
Reliability Rating: 5/5

Much like other used midsize SUVs on the list, the 2016 Nissan Murano’s reliability ratings aim to impress. Consumer Reports even gave the 2016 model a five out of five reliability rating, which is pretty hard to argue with. The used Nissan Murano doesn’t have many trouble spots to contend with either. According to Consumer Reports, the most common Nissan Murano problems include the midsize SUV’s brakes, body, in-car electronics, and power equipment.

Perhaps the only downside to the 2016 Nissan Murano is its owner satisfaction rating. Consumer Reports gave the used midsize SUV a three out of five owner satisfaction rating. While that score is about average, it is relatively disappointing. Only 62% of Murano owners said they would consider rebuying the SUV too.

Which used midsized SUV is the best fit for you?

Shopping for a reliable five-year-old used midsize SUV doesn’t have to be a stressful experience. In fact, with Consumer Reports’ picks for the most reliable used midsize SUVs in hand, you’ve got plenty of options worth considering.

RELATED: 12 Best AWD SUVs of 2021 According to U.S. News, the 2022 Hyundai Tucson Tops the List