Skip to main content

What is the most reliable full-size pickup truck of 2023? Typical answers are the Ford F-150 and Toyota Tundra. The F-150 has been a best-seller for years, and the Toyota brand is synonymous with reliability. However, not all experts rank these two models at the top of their reliability lists. Let’s examine which new trucks are the most reliable.

What are the most reliable full-size pickup trucks based on Consumer Reports surveys?

A black 2023 Ram 1500 parked at dusk
2023 Ram 1500 | Stellantis

The argument against the F-150 and Tundra begins with Consumer Reports. Its top six 2023 trucks for reliability are as follows:

  1. Ram 1500
  2. Nissan Titan
  3. Toyota Tundra
  4. Ford F-150
  5. GMC Sierra 1500
  6. Chevrolet Silverado 150

They are the non-electric full-size trucks in the class and show that the Ram 1500 repeats as the winner for reliability. Before the Ram 1500 took the top spot, the Toyota Tundra ranked highest with Consumer Reports, but even a new Tundra model wasn’t enough to unseat the Ram as the most reliable truck in its class.

Consumer Reports gets its vehicle reliability data from car owners’ survey responses. The nonprofit organization says it received details about more than 300,000 vehicles in its 2022 surveys, which covered 2000 to 2022 and some early 2023 models.

What’s the most reliable truck according to J.D. Power scores?

2022 Chevrolet Silverado ZR2 on a Hilly Trail
2022 Chevy Silverado ZR2 | Chevrolet

To find the most reliable pickup rated by J.D. Power, we have to dig deeper than the overall scores. The market research firm ranks the 2023 GMC Sierra 1500 as the overall winner but doesn’t consider it the most reliable. J.D. Power’s reliability scores, on a scale of zero to 100, give us this ranking:

  1. Chevrolet Silverado 1500, 87
  2. GMC Sierra 1500, 86
  3. Ford F-150, 86
  4. Ram 1500, 80
  5. Toyota Tundra, 70

As of this writing, J.D. Power hasn’t rated the Nissan Titan. Strangely, this is the second source that doesn’t place the Ford or Toyota truck on top.

Does other expert data make things clearer?

2023 Toyota Tundra Playing Around on Some Rocks
2023 Toyota Tundra | Toyota

In our efforts to find the most reliable full-size pickup truck of 2023, a third opinion could make things clearer or muddy the waters further. iSeeCars ranks the most reliable trucks as follows:

  1. Toyota Tundra
  2. Ford F-150
  3. Chevy Silverado 1500
  4. Nissan Titan
  5. GMC Sierra 1500
  6. Ram 1500

The Tundra received 8.6 out of 10, while the F-150 earned 8.5. The average reliability score for this category is 8.1.

Is the most reliable full-size pickup truck a Ford or Toyota?

The answer to that question depends on the source. Consumer Reports and J.D. Power don’t list the F-150 or Tundra at the top, but iSeeCars does. That doesn’t make searching for the most dependable truck easy.

 If it’s any consolation, these pickups are all rated closely, and none is considered unreliable. That could make choosing a model with everything you want easier, even if it’s not the most reliable full-size pickup truck of 2023.


Does the 2023 Ford F-150 Actually Offer Many Changes to This Top-Selling Pickup Truck?