Skip to main content


What is the most reliable full-size pickup truck of 2023? Typical answers are the Ford F-150 and Toyota Tundra. The F-150 has been the best-selling truck in America for several years running, and the Toyota name seems to be next to the word reliability in the dictionary. Strangely, not all experts put these two trucks at the top of their reliability lists. Let’s dig in and see which trucks are most reliable for 2023.

What are the most reliable full-size pickup trucks, according to Consumer Reports?

2023 Ram 1500 Parked in Front of a House - This is the most reliable full-size pickup truck according to Consumer Reports
2023 Ram 1500 | Ram

The argument against the F-150 and Tundra begins with Consumer Reports. The top six trucks for reliability from this expert organization are:

  1. Ram 1500
  2. Nissan Titan
  3. Toyota Tundra
  4. Ford F-150
  5. GMC Sierra 1500
  6. Chevrolet Silverado 150

These six are the non-electric full-size trucks in the class and show that the Ram 1500 repeats as the winner for reliability. Before the Ram 1500 took over the top spot, the Toyota Tundra ranked highest with CR, but even a new model of the Tundra wasn’t enough to unseat the Ram as the most reliable truck in this class.

What’s J.D. Power’s most reliable truck?

2022 Chevrolet Silverado ZR2 on a Hilly Trail
2022 Chevrolet Silverado ZR2 | Chevrolet

To find the most reliable pickup rated by J.D. Power, we have to dig deeper than the overall scores. The 2023 GMC Sierra 1500 is the overall winner as the best truck from this expert, but it’s not the most reliable. The reliability scores give us this ranking:

  1. Chevrolet Silverado 1500 – 87
  2. GMC Sierra 1500 – 86
  3. Ford F-150 – 86
  4. Ram 1500 – 80
  5. Toyota Tundra – 70

As of this writing, J.D. Power hasn’t rated the Nissan Titan. Strangely, this is the second publication that doesn’t have the Ford or Toyota trucks in the top spot.

Does another expert opinion make things clearer?

2023 Toyota Tundra Playing Around on Some Rocks
2023 Toyota Tundra | Toyota

In our efforts to find the most reliable full-size pickup truck of 2023, a third opinion could make things clearer or muddy the waters more than they already are. Turning to, the most reliable trucks are:

  1. Toyota Tundra
  2. Ford F-150
  3. Chevrolet Silverado 1500
  4. Nissan Titan
  5. GMC Sierra 1500
  6. Ram 1500

The Tundra receives an 8.6 out of 10, while the F-150 achieves a rating of 8.5. The average reliability score for this category is 8.1.

Is the most reliable full-size pickup truck a Ford or Toyota?

It’s easy to see the answer to this question depends entirely on which expert opinion you choose to follow. Both Consumer Reports and J.D. Power don’t have the F-150 or Tundra listed at the top, but iSeeCars does. This doesn’t make things easy when searching for the right truck to drive.

 If it’s any consolation, these trucks are all rated pretty closely, and none are considered unreliable. This could make it much easier to choose the pickup with everything you want, even if it’s not the most reliable full-size pickup truck of 2023.


Does the 2023 Ford F-150 Actually Offer Many Changes to This Top-Selling Pickup Truck?