Skip to main content

Which used midsize and large cars have the highest reliability ratings? There are a handful of brands you can consistently look to in order to find long-lasting cars, but nailing down specific makes, models, and years can be tricky. Fortunately, Consumer Reports collected a list of the most reliable used vehicles to buy, and these five popular sedans made the list.

Explore the five best three-year-old sedans that will actually last.

5. 2019 Toyota Avalon full-size sedan

We’ll start with the biggest car in the ranking: the impressive Toyota Avalon. This full-sized sedan was redesigned for the 2019 model year (MY) so you’ll benefit from any newer changes or updates, even if you buy one used. It boasts high owner satisfaction ratings, it’s decently fuel-efficient, and its V6 engine provides plenty of fun.

How much does a 2019 Toyota Avalon cost? Finding a used model for under $30,000 may be tricky, but you should be able to find some options for less than $35,000. Along with being one of the most reliable brands, Toyota cars are known for holding their value.

Interior shot of the top trim level of the 2019 Toyota Avalon, one of the most reliable used cars
2019 Toyota Avalon interior | Toyota

4. 2019 Honda Accord midsize sedan

A used Honda Accord is almost always a good idea, particularly if you’re looking for one of the most reliable pre-owned vehicles. The 2019 Accords you’ll find on dealership lots right now are more than likely lease returns. Leased cars tend to have lower mileage and be in better condition than their owned counterparts—so you could find a real steal.

How much does a 2019 Honda Accord cost? Honda is another brand with an exceptional talent for retaining value, so you’ll likely need to spend between $25,000 and $35,000, depending on trim level.

3. 2019 Mazda6 midsize sedan

The 2019 Mazda6 is a surprisingly efficient sedan along with being reliable. It’s likely to return around 32 mpg combined from its standard four-cylinder models, but it doesn’t compromise performance for fuel economy. The Mazda6 is fun to drive and really channels that “Zoom-Zoom” spirit.

How much does a 2019 Mazda6 cost? Used-car prices are on the up and up currently, so you’ll likely find a used Mazda6 for sale in the range of $20,000 – $30,000. 

Staged shot of a 2019 Mazda6, one of the most reliable used cars, set against a backdrop of an expensive house surrounded by palm trees
2019 Mazda6 | Mazda

2. 2019 Subaru Legacy midsize sedan

The 2019 Legacy is the only model in this list with standard all-wheel drive, making it one of the most reliable used cars in multiple areas. It’s a long-lasting sedan that can be counted on in inclement weather and on rough roads. Win-win.

How much does a 2019 Subaru Legacy cost? Price will vary depending on region but expect to pay between $24,000 – $30,000 for a Legacy in good condition.

1. 2019 Toyota Camry midsize sedan

Ah, yes, the Camry—wouldn’t be a reliable used cars list without a handful of Toyotas. The 2019 Toyota Camry is almost guaranteed to outlast all of your friends’ cooler, sportier, more expensive cars. Its roomy interior, comfortable ride, and array of safety features make any modern used Camry a smart choice.

How much does a 2019 Toyota Camry cost? Consumer Reports estimates that this model may list for between $23,725 and $34,500. That doesn’t quite make the Camry one of the most reliable used cars under $20,000, but it gets you close. Opt for a 2016 or older model and you’ll likely find exactly what you’re looking for.

Moving shot of a 2019 Toyota Camry sedan driving in a city
2019 Toyota Camry | Toyota

Set your sights on one of these most reliable used sedans

Nobody knows what the used-car market is going to look like over the next year or two. Buying a used car that’s built to last and won’t break the bank could be a smart move. “Cheap reliable used car” is often an oxymoron because typically, you get what you pay for. 

But with one of these five long-lasting sedans, you can have your cake and eat it, too. 


Which Honda Accord Models Have Leather Seats?