Consumer Reports Worst Midsize Luxury Car Is Also the Most Expensive

When you invest in something more expensive than other options, you might presume you’re getting better quality. But that’s not always the case, even when you’re talking about buying cars. Consumer Reports keeps this in mind when the team evaluates new cars, offering recommendations accordingly.

Looking at the midsize luxury car segment and subsequent recommendations by Consumer Reports, there’s one car, the 2022 Maserati Ghibli, that stands out as a potential match, being the worst on the list and the most expensive. The 2022 Maserati Ghibli is in the spotlight for this report, but not in a good way.

Which is the cheapest midsize luxury car?

A grey Maserati Ghibli, the worst midsize luxury car, driven down the road.
Maserati Ghibli | Maserati

When Consumer Reports evaluates a new car, the team is diligent about going over every detail through the lens of the car-buying consumer. In this luxury car breakdown of contenders, a few brands emerge as the first-choice considerations in certain areas. The cheapest midsize luxury sedan, for example, is the 2022 Lexus ES. 

Citing a price range of $40,950 to $51,330, Consumer Reports says the Lexus ES is the cheapest luxury car you can buy in this midsize class. It also earns the Consumer Reports recommendation with above-average scores and ratings from the Consumer Reports team and the consumer-based surveys. So, it’s not just cheap; it’s also a great car. 

Which is the worst and most expensive on this list?

At the other end of the ratings and price spectrum, you might be wondering which luxury car comes in as the most expensive. And which model earns the lowest scores, making it the worst on the list overall? Unfortunately, both of those questions can be answered by the same car. 

The 2022 Maserati Ghibli comes in with the highest price range of other contenders in its class. Consumer Reports says its base MSRP range is a whopping $76,200 to $110,600 before including any destination charges or extras. But it’s not just the most expensive on this Consumer Reports roster. It’s also the model with the lowest overall ratings and Consumer Reports scores. 

Where the 2022 Maserati Ghibli goes wrong is in its “predicted reliability” and “predicted owner satisfaction” categories, both of which are usually based on the experiences of owners from older models.

But that’s not all. Consumer Reports gives the Ghibli below-average ratings in ride quality, fuel economy, and smog ratings. Some more specific drawbacks and dislikes include a tight backseat, a lackluster interior finish, difficult visibility, and a fussy gear selector.

Which is the highest-rated midsize luxury car, according to Consumer Reports?

If you’re not necessarily swayed by the cheapest luxury car, according to Consumer Reports, you might be more interested in which model earned the highest ratings and recommendations overall. Based on the full battery of road testing and consumer survey evaluations, the 2022 Audi A6 might be the next car for you.

The 2022 Audi A6 could be the sweet spot of excellent scores, great feedback, and reasonably priced midsize luxury sedans. Predicted reliability is good, road-testing scores are well above average, and the Audi A6 earns the Consumer Reports recommended checkmark of approval. It’s also demonstrating excellent ratings in ride quality, cabin quietness, braking capability, and handling.

If you base your luxury car-buying decisions on the recommendation and endorsements of Consumer Reports, the 2022 Maserati Ghibli might be the car to avoid. It’s not all bad and does have some redeeming qualities that some buyers will appreciate. But according to Consumer Reports scores, it comes in last in the midsize luxury car space and also happens to be the most expensive.

RELATED: Maserati Is the Luxury Brand You Forgot About, Here Is Everything They Offer in 2022