Consumer Reports Doesn’t Recommend MotorTrend’s Best Full-Size SUV

Full-size SUVs with three-rows of seating are excellent vehicles to own. Anyone who requires ample space for passengers and cargo will fulfill their needs with any full-size model. However, not all experts agree on which ones are the best. MotorTrend’s best full-size SUV is the 2022 Chevrolet Suburban, but Consumer Reports doesn’t even recommend buying one.

What is MotorTrend’s best full-size SUV?

MotorTrend and Consumer Reports disagree on the 2022 Chevrolet Suburban, only 1 thinks it's the best full-size SUV.
2022 Chevy Suburban | Chevrolet

According to MotorTrend, the best full-size three-row SUV is the 2022 Chevrolet Suburban. The reviewer gave it an 8.4/10, which is higher than every other model on the list. In second place is the Ford Expedition, which is Consumer Reports’ favorite model. What does MT like about the Chevy Suburban?

Firstly, the publication boasts of the Suburban’s comfortable ride. Like many full-size SUVs, the Suburban feels luxurious cruising along the road. Next, the roomy interior is a highlight for MT. One of the biggest draws to vehicles in this class is the interior space. Chevrolet’s offering provides a highly spacious interior that MT believes trumps most other models. Finally, the Suburban has responsive powertrains.

There are three available powertrains for the 2022 Chevy Suburban. Two V8 engines and a turbodiesel make up the engine offerings. Moreover, the 5.3-liter V8 makes 355 horsepower, the 6.2-liter V8 makes 420 hp, and the 3.0-liter turbodiesel I-6 277 hp.

Consumer Reports doesn’t recommend the 2022 Chevrolet Suburban

RELATED: 2023 Toyota Sequoia vs. 2022 Chevy Suburban: The Sequoia Makes a Leaping Catch for the Winning Touchdown

As of May 2022, Consumer Reports reviewed seven different full-size SUVs. One of those is MotorTrend’s favorite model, but CR doesn’t recommend consumers purchase one. Out of seven different models, only two are recommended. The 2022 Ford Expedition and the Toyota Sequoia sit at the top of the leaderboards. After that, the overall scores drop significantly, finally reaching the Suburban in fourth place.

CR gave Chevy’s full-size model a 41 out of 100 overall. Compared to the top-rated Expedition, which earned a 73, that’s very poor. Why would two respected reviewers have such vastly different opinions on this model? First, Consumer Reports heavily weighs reliability in its reviews. MT doesn’t list it as an attribute for its judgment, but CR gave the Chevy Suburban the worst possible score for predicted reliability. Predicted reliability is based on previous model years, and the Suburban has had significant, frequent mechanical problems for many years.

Next, CR dislikes a lot about the Chevrolet full-size SUV. In short, braking, agility, the gear selector, high step-in, visibility, and fuel economy are all listed as negatives. While the publication agrees with MT about the interior space and comfortable ride, it falls short elsewhere.

MotorTrend and Consumer Reports disagree on the best full-size SUV

MotorTrend named the 2022 Chevrolet Suburban the best full-size SUV of 2022. However, another respected publication, Consumer Reports, doesn’t recommend it to buyers. Which reviewer’s opinion do you think is more justified? Overall, the Chevy Suburban is one of the top picks for anyone who requires a full-size SUV. If you’re looking for experts to agree on vehicle reviews, you’ll be searching for a while because it doesn’t happen often. Although both of these outlets like the Ford Expedition, which finished top two in both full-size SUV rankings.

RELATED: Should You Buy the 2022 GMC Yukon XL or the 2022 Chevy Suburban?