Consumer Reports Best Used Cars From Honda and Toyota for Around $5,000

Used cars can be expensive right now, but not everyone can afford the price increase. Consumer Reports has some of the best used cars under $5,000, even right now. Which vehicles made this budget-friendly list?

Best used cars under $5,000 according to Consumer Reports

The Honda Civic is one of the best used cars
The Honda Civic is one of the best used cars | National Motor Museum/Heritage Images via Getty Images

Consumer Reports has various years offered for each model because the price can vary depending on the equipment. Some models might be more expensive due to additional safety features or lower mileage.

  1. 2009 to 2011 Honda Civic
  2. 2007 to 2010 Honda Fit
  3. 2005 to 2009 Toyota Corolla
  4. 2005 to 2009 Toyota Prius
  5. 2004 to 2007 Honda Accord

The 2009 to 2011 Honda Civic is one of the best used cars

The 2009 to 2011 Honda Civic received the stamp of approval from Consumer Reports. It is a green choice that has remained a reliable small car, even 10 years later. Owners of the Honda Civic are generally satisfied with the used car throughout the years.

Price Range:  $5,975 – $9,575

OWNER REPORTED MPG:  30 mpg

Try to find a 2007 to 2010 Honda Fit with electronic stability control (ESC)

RELATED: Best Toyota Cars & SUVs for the Money in 2021

The 2007 to 2010 Honda Fit has a roomy interior and seats that fold down for even more space. Consumer Reports found that it scored well on the road test and was fairly reliable overall. If possible, CR suggests getting a model with electronic stability control (ESC). This is an important safety feature worth paying a bit more for.

Price Range:  $6,475 – $7,375

OWNER REPORTED MPG:  32 mpg

The ever-reliable Toyota Corolla 2005 to 2009

consumer reports best used cars
The Toyota Corolla is one of the best used cars | Manan Vatsyayana/AFP via Getty Images

The 2005 to 2009 Toyota Corolla is about as reliable as it can be. It scored well on all of the Consumer Reports tests. It won’t be the most exciting ride, but it is comfortable and handles well. Buyers might have difficulty finding ESC within the price range, but it might be worth it. CR says a 2009 Toyota Corolla or later will offer the most comprehensive safety features.

Price Range:  $4,425 – $4,850

OWNER REPORTED MPG:  30 mpg

Consumer Reports found the 2005 to 2009 Toyota Prius reliable

Looking at the 2005 to 2009 Toyota Prius, Consumer Reports gave it high marks on all tests. It scored well on the road test, reliability, and owner satisfaction. With 42 mpg and a price of around $5,900, the Toyota Prius is one of the best used cars. CR says to aim for a 2007 Toyota Prius or later due to ESC and standard curtain airbags.

Price Range:  $5,900

OWNER REPORTED MPG:  42 mpg

The 2004 to 2007 Honda Accord is a budget-friendly used car

The 2004 to 2007 Honda Accord is roomy, reliable, and kept owners satisfied throughout the years of ownership. The V6 engine is the more desirable engine choice. Consumer Reports says to try to find a 2005 or newer due to standard stability control, an important safety feature.

Price Range:  $3,575 – $4,675

OWNER REPORTED MPG:  25 mpg

Be aware of important safety features

When shopping for a used car, staying within a budget is essential, but some safety features are worth paying more for. Consumer Reports offered some things to look out for so that buyers can find the most affordable best new car available.

RELATED: Consumer Reports Suggests Avoiding These Popular New Cars