This Chevy Sports Car Got Consumer Reports’ ‘Never Buy’ Label

Few vehicles evoke a sense of nostalgic Americana and joyous thrills like a Chevrolet sports car. But shop with caution when seeking out your next American muscle car. As many 2017 Chevy Camaro owners found out, your would-be dream machine could be a hunk of junk.

What makes this particular Camaro a cautionary tale? We’ll explain why trusted industry experts recommend avoiding this Chevy sports car. Using the lessons learned from owners of this problematic vehicle can help you make a smarter buying decision in the future.

Don’t ignore the 2017 Chevy Camaro’s biggest red flag

A yellow 2017 Chevy Camaro driving down a country road with trees in the background
The 2017 Chevy Camaro in action | Chevrolet

If there’s any fatal flaw with this used Camaro, it’s the model’s dependability. You may feel comfortable sacrificing practicality for a thrilling driving experience. After all, you’re buying a muscle car, not a commuter vehicle. However, you’re still likely to use it as your daily driver.

Consumer Reports gave the 2017 Chevy Camaro a horrendous 1/5 reliability rating. Notable trouble spots include the transmission, suspension, brakes, power equipment, and body integrity. This trait isn’t exclusive to the 2017 iteration, as the latest Camaro is also one of Chevrolet’s least-reliable models.

Camaros equipped with the available V8 engine and eight-speed automatic transmission were a source of frequent issues. Multiple owners reported that these 2017 Camaros “shudder” when traveling between 20-50 MPH or 1,300-1,500 RPM. 

Due to its reliability issues, it’s not surprising Consumer Reports put the 2017 Camaro on its ‘Used Cars to Avoid Buying’ list. However, other negative factors also likely attributed to this dishonor.

This Chevy Sports Car has other annoying drawbacks, too

An inside look at the black interior of the 2017 Chevrolet Camaro
The 2017 Chevy Camaro’s interior | Chevrolet

RELATED: Forget the Old Ads: These Are Chevy’s Most Reliable Models

Getting behind the wheel of a powerful, athletic vehicle should feel like a joyride. But the 2017 Chevy Camaro just doesn’t fit the script. Consumer Reports’ review of the car praised its handling and potent engine lineup. However, the publication took issue with the Camaro’s comfort level.

Consumer Reports noted how the 2017 Chevy Camaro’s front seats lack adjustable back support. That’s an automatic dealbreaker for anyone who has a long commute to work. You won’t want to use this vehicle for any long drives, either. The Camaro provides little headroom, and its rear seats are all-but-unusable for adults.

Additionally, Chevrolet didn’t equip any Camaro models with front-crash prevention systems. This absence is quite notable considering the 2017 Camaro’s average retail price – $19,500-$49,425, according to Consumer Reports.

Try one of these used 2017 Chevy Camaro alternatives

RELATED: The Top-Rated 2021 Sports Cars on Consumer Reports Couldn’t Be More Different

So, you still want a sporty car but don’t feel comfortable playing the odds? We don’t blame you. Thankfully, we’ve found several other fun-to-drive used vehicles that you’ll love. Best of all, you can get these models for around the same price as an entry-level used 2017 Chevy Camaro.

The Dodge Challenger resembles the Camaro with its classic muscle car design. However, it doesn’t suffer from most of the same flaws. The Challenger is surprisingly reliable, and you can nab one for relatlively cheap. 

Used 2016 Challenger models retail for about the same amount as the 2017 Chevy Camaro. However, we recommend opting for a used 2015 Dodge Challenger to take advantage of huge savings. Its feature lineup is virtually identical to its successor, as Dodge didn’t introduce any significant new changes until 2017.
Alternatively, you could opt for a used 2016-2017 Cadillac CTS if you want to stay within the GM family. This sedan delivers thrilling performance with a luxurious twist. Plus, the U.S. News & World Report named the CTS the Best Luxury Midsize Car of 2017.