10 Vehicles That Won’t Save You Money on the Used Market

BRISTOL, ENGLAND - OCTOBER 06: A customer looks at a brand new Mazda car that is offered for sale on the forecourt of a main motor car dealer in Brislington on October 6, 2015 in Bristol, England. Latest data from the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT) show a record 462,517 new cars were registered in the UK last month, a 8.6% year on year increase, and that total sales in the year to date have hit 2,096,886, 7.1 percent higher than the same point last year and the first time the two million mark has been passed in September since 2004.
While pre-owned is the best call for a luxury sedan, there are many cars you should not buy used. | Matt Cardy/Getty Images

Should you buy new or used? For car shoppers, it’s one of the eternal questions. When we looked at vehicles that had the highest depreciation after just one year of ownership, many well-made cars and trucks were clear candidates to buy used. Dealing with a lightly owned model could save consumers as much as $20,000, and you only have to wait one year after they leave the dealership. But it’s not all that simple.

Some consumers simply refuse to deal with a car that’s been in the hands of another owner. There might be concerns about how a previous owner handled oil changes and maintenance, not to mention the way they added options and made decisions about the interior. Buying new means you can mold the car in your style and personality.

You might even get a great value by avoiding the used market, depending on the model. According to a study by iSeeCars.com, there might only be a 7% price difference after one year of ownership. Here are 10 models that held their value best over that time and you’d be better off buying new.

10. Range Rover

View of a Land Rover Range Rover on the trail
Luxury SUV consumers won’t get much of a discount buying a Range Rover used. | Land Rover

While luxury sedans like Mercedes C300 and Jaguar XF depreciate over 30% in just one year of ownership, luxury SUVs fared better in the study. The Range Rover lost just 10.6% of value in another owner’s hands for 12 months. While that still adds up to $11,817 off the average sale price, consumers paying around six figures for this vehicle would be better off buying new.

9. Toyota Highlander

Side view of 2017 Toyota Highlander in black
2017 Toyota Highlander | Toyota

The 2017 Toyota Highlander impressed the critics during first drives late in 2016, and the data shows there is no reason to wait to buy this model used. After one year of ownership, sellers saw prices dip just $4,131 (10.4%) on average. Following the first year of ownership, most Highlander buyers are sold for the long run. In a study of vehicles people keep 10 years or longer, this model was among the best.

8. Subaru Impreza

2015 Subaru Impreza parked in the snow
A new Impreza is hardly more expensive than a lightly used model | Subaru

It is no coincidence Subaru owners are often satisfied, loyal customers. The auto brand continues growing its consumer base in the U.S., and that means higher demand and lower depreciation. In the case of Impreza, there is little evidence you will save by buying used, especially after one year. Depreciation held at 10.3% ($2,321) in the iSeeCars study.

7. Subaru WRX

A blue 2015 Subaru WRX rounding a corner
Popular cars like the WRX equal higher prices on the used market. | Subaru

So you want to increase the fun factor with a Subaru WRX? Our advice is to build the car of your dreams in a dealership rather than settling for a late-model-year version on the used market. After 12 months in the hands of a new owner, WRX only dipped 9.2% on the secondhand market. For an average of $3,048 more, consumers can buy a custom car new.

6. Subaru XV Crosstrek

A man and woman load surfboards on top of a Subaru XV Crosstrek Hybrid.
Forget love — low depreciation is what gives a Subaru its edge. | Subaru

According to iSeeCars.com CEO Phong Ly, “Subaru as a brand [is] currently in high demand with buyers,” and that means lower depreciation. XV Crosstrek owners who sold after 12 months of ownership saw an average of $2,393 (9.2%) difference from the new car price. For a model known for its safety and dependability, it’s a small premium to pay.

5. Nissan Frontier

The 2015 Nissan Frontier shown in red on a rock mountain path
Pickups like the Nissan Frontier have low depreciation on the U.S. market. | Frontier

Along with SUVs and popular sedans, pickup trucks have enjoyed low depreciation with gas prices holding steady. According to iSeeCars data, owners who sold their Frontiers after a year saw just 8.8% depreciation. On a model that starts below $20,000, used buyers saved an average of just $2,415. Buying new is a much better plan of attack with Frontier. Save your pickup the wear an owner can put on it in one year.

4. Honda Fit

2016 Honda Fit in red
In a list dominated by SUVs and pickups, the tiny Honda Fit stands out from the pack. | Honda

If one car stands out on this list, Honda Fit would be it. The tiny, fun-to-drive sedan boasts impressive cargo space at a low sticker price, and there’s no reason to buy used. According to iSeeCars data, Fit owners saw prices drop just 8.8% when turning to sell after a year. In other words, used buyers saved an average of $1,495 by choosing a pre-owned model.

3. GMC Canyon

A black GMC Canyon parked on a scenic mountain range
GMC Canyon | General Motors

GM’s midsize trucks have been very popular since their re-entry on the U.S. market. In the GMC Canyon, consumers find an option that holds its value well after leaving a dealer’s lot. Canyons showed a dip in value of just 8.1% one year from the date of the original owner purchase. At an average of $2,860, the rationale for buying used is pretty thin for this model.

2. Jeep Wrangler Unlimited

The 2016 Jeep Wrangler Unlimited 75th Anniversary edition in army green
It may not rank high on safety, but Wrangler is a popular vehicle that holds its value. | Jeep

There’s no question people love their Jeeps. Despite being fraught with safety risks and a high recall probability, these trail dominators have owners that rarely abandon them. To pry a Wrangler Unlimited a year after the original owner bought one, you’d have to pay about 92% of the original sticker price. Why not invest the $3,076 and break one in on a favorite trail? Seems like a small price to pay for a decade or so of thrills.

1. Chevrolet Colorado

A Chevy Colorado Crew Cab Truck
The Chevy Colorado Crew Cab | Micah Wright/Autos Cheat Sheet

Among the top 10 cars and trucks that held their value best after 12 months, none could match the Chevrolet Colorado. The bow-tie brand’s midsize pickup was the only one that depreciated less than 8%, and it beat the standard by a lot. After a year in a new owner’s hand, Colorado fetched 93% of its purchase price on the used market. Original owners only saw an average of just $2,311 get knocked off the sticker price for choosing a used model. Buy it new.

Follow Eric on Twitter @EricSchaalNY.