The Best Used Toyota Tacoma Years to Buy Over $25,000

When it comes to the best used compact trucks to buy, the Toyota Tacoma comes in a large number of configurations and styles. These are some of the best used Toyota Tacoma years to buy over $25,000 that ranked high on the list of compact trucks.

2018 is one of the best used Toyota Tacoma years to buy over $25,000

The best used Toyota Tacoma years under $25,000 to buy
A 2018 Toyota Tacoma pickup truck | Toyota

When U.S. News ranked the best compact trucks to buy used, the 2018 Toyota Tacoma was at the top of the list. The Tacoma is a great all-around truck with off-roading capabilities and high tow ratings. It can tow up to 6,800 pounds when properly equipped and has a payload of 1,620 pounds. J.D. Power and U.S. News gave the 2018 version a reliability rating of four and a half stars out of five. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) gave this pickup truck high scores on necessary tests like the moderate front overlap and the roof strength tests.

Average Price Paid: $24,627 – $40,908

2016 was another good year for the Toyota Tacoma

RELATED: Only 3 Compact Pickup Trucks Are Recommended by Consumer Reports

2016 brought a redesign for the Toyota Tacoma pickup truck. It fits between four and five passengers, and buyers could opt for four-wheel drive or rear-wheel drive. The IIHS gave the 2016 Tacoma truck high scores on many tests, like the rear crash and roof strength test, but the headlights need improving. Similar to the last option, it received a four-and-a-half-star reliability rating. Towing for the 2016 truck worked out to 6,800 pounds, making it one of the best used Toyota Tacoma years to buy.

Average Price Paid: $23,107 – $34,283

The 2015 Tacoma has the highest reliability rating

What makes the 2015 Toyota Tacoma better or worse than the other options? This year offered some new engine options that got between 159 and 236 horsepower. Fuel economy numbers were between 15 and 21 mpg in the city and 19 to 25 mpg on the highway. It also received a five-star reliability rating from J.D. Power and U.S. News. For this year, the Tacoma can tow up to 6,500 pounds with the V6 engine and optional tow package. Otherwise, it can tow 3,400 pounds.

Average Price Paid: $19,983 – $30,032

Don’t overlook the 2017 Toyota truck

The 2017 Toyota Tacoma offered buyers a quality interior and a low cost of ownership over the years. That same strong V6 is powering the Tacoma and doing a fine job of it. Technology features for this year are described as easy to use, and the TRD Pro trim debuted this year. The reliability score dropped to three and a half stars for 2017. For the base engine, Toyota equipped it with the ability to tow 3,500 pounds. With the V6 Tow package, that gets a bump up to 6,800 pounds and includes additional features like a heavy-duty alternator.

Average Price Paid: $24,117 – $39,245

2019 was a good year for the Toyota Tacoma

Even though the 2019 Toyota Tacoma is the newest option on the list, it came in 12th place on the list of used compact trucks over $25,000. As you might come to expect, the 2019 truck is excellent at off-roading and has high towing capacities. It is also projected to have below-average ownership costs over the years. The reliability rating for this year is four out of five, which is still above average for a pickup truck. When properly equipped, the 2019 Tacoma can tow 6,800 pounds.

Average Price Paid: $26,057 – $44,764

The good news is that every year of the Toyota Tacoma is a good buy. The bad news is everyone is aware of that and wants a Tacoma too. Don’t be afraid to search private sellers or websites like Bring a Trailer if you want particular specs or setups.

RELATED: 5 Pickup Trucks with the Worst Resale Value for 2022