Best Used Toyota Tacoma Pickup Truck: Models to Hunt for and 1 to Avoid

The best used Toyota Tacoma pickup truck years might surprise you! In fact, one year stands out as a good year to avoid buying. The rest of the years offer reliability and good safety scores from major companies. So, how does one find a good used Toyota Tacoma?

The 2021 year is one of the best used Toyota Tacoma pickup trucks

The best used Toyota Tacoma pickup truck years
Two Toyota Tacoma trucks in the dirt | Toyota

While 2021 might seem new, there are plenty of used Toyota Tacoma pickup trucks out there right now. A 2021 model will likely have some warranty remaining, both from the factory or the dealership. Consumer Reports’ near-perfect score for reliability and owner satisfaction is a good indication of a solid Toyota pickup truck. Finding a used 2021 Toyota Tacoma pickup truck might be harder because people tend to hold onto it for longer. It has a high resale value and is great for light off-road averntures.

Average Retail Price: $32,450 – $52,675

Trade-in Price: $29,400 – $48,700

2020 was one of the best used Toyota Tacoma pickup truck years

RELATED: New Toyota Battery Electric Vehicles: Electric Toyota Tacoma, FJ Cruiser Concepts

When the experts at Consumer Reports rated the 2020 Toyota Tacoma, it was mostly positive. Owners seemed satisfied with the Tacoma down the line and the reliability history continued on a positive note. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) gave this Toyota truck a Top safety pick award. Crashworthiness tests like the front moderate overlap, side crash, and rear crash, all received the highest score possible.

Average Retail Price: $30,700 – $50,175

Trade-in Price: $27,680 – $46,395

The 2015 version was still a reliable option

The 2015 Toyota Tacoma was the last year before a major redesign. Even though it looked a little dated, it is still one of the best used Toyota Tacoma pickup trucks in recent history. It had above-average scores for reliability and owners reported few problems over the years. Fuel economy wasn’t such a selling point back then, which lest the 2015 Tacoma with 19 mpg overall.

Average Retail Price: $17,800 – $27,200

Trade-in Price: $14,090 – $23,965

The 2019 model was not the best used Toyota Tacoma pickup truck year

The 2019 Tacoma is definitely the model to avoid. It has the lowest reliability and owner satisfaction scores in recent years when considering Consumer Reports ratings. Both received low scores, culminating in far below-average ratings overall. Owners reported that the driving experience was lacking, as was the interior comfort. The truck holds it value well, overall, but even the 2019 version saw a slight slump in resale value. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) gave the 2019 Tacoma above-average scores on its crashworthiness tests.

Average Retail Price: $28,225 – $46,350

Trade-in Price: $25,175 – $42,690

Toyota is one of two brands known for making vehicles that can run for more than 200,000 miles. That title does not come easily and Toyota trucks and SUVs have earned it. As long as you keep up with routine maintenance such as oil changes, coolant flushes, and keeping an eye on your tires/suspension, your Tacoma will remain a loyal truck.

RELATED: Toyota Tacoma Is the Best-Selling Small Pickup for 16 Consecutive Years