Best Used Pickup Trucks Under $10,000 – the Top Pick Comes From Japan

It is no secret that the average brand-new truck has become quite expensive in recent years. As a result, many buyers are turning to the used market. With so many carmakers and model years, it isn’t easy to sort through the best options. To help, we’ll be looking at the best used pickup trucks under $10,000.

This list comes from a study performed by iSeeCars. The trucks are categorized by their propensity to surpass 200,000 miles. Additionally, iSeeCars gives us their average towing capacity and pricing. However, it is worth pointing out that due to high demand, the used car market has shown high volatility as of late.

Best used full-sized trucks under $10,000

An image of a Toyota Tundra parked outside, one of the best used pickup trucks under $10,000.
Toyota Tundra | Toyota

Let’s start at the top of this lift of best used pickup trucks with the full-size options. At the very top, you’ll find the 2005 Toyota Tundra. iSeeCars found that 2.9 percent of these trucks eventually surpass 200,000 miles. On average, these trucks can tow up to 4,700 lb and should cost you around $10,096.

Next up is the 2005 Chevrolet Silverado 1500. Aside from towing more than the Toyota at 7,063 lb, the Silverado costs less on average, totaling around $8,435. However, only 2 percent of these trucks ever surpass 200,000 miles, significantly less than the Tundra.

Next up in this list of best used pickup trucks is the 2007 Ford F-150. As its model year suggests, you can get a newer F-150 for similar money to the aforementioned trucks. With an average cost of $9,496, this full-size truck can still tow 7,553 lb. In total, iSeeCars found that 1.9 percent of these trucks surpass 200,000 miles.

If power is what you’re after, then you’ll need the 2007 Nissan Titan. For $9,591 on average, you get a max towing rating of 8,874 lb. However, it is worth noting that only 1.8 percent of these trucks surpass 200,000 miles.

Best used mid-size pickup trucks under $20,000

An image of a Nissan Frontier parked outdoors.
Nissan Frontier | Nissan

RELATED: Should the $67,500 Rivian R1T Be Your First Electric Pickup Truck?

If you prefer a mid-size truck for less than $10,000, then one option stands out in this list. It’s the 2007 Nissan Frontier, and it should cost you around $8,694. Despite this, the Frontier has a max towing rating of 5,830 lb, battling even some full-size trucks.

The frontier stands out because of its towers over competitors such as the 2007 GMC Canyon and 2007 Ford Ranger. While these trucks will cost less on average at $8,060 and $8,112, respectively, they can’t tow nearly as much. For example, the GMC tops out at 3,589 lb while the Ford can’t handle more than 2,460 lb, says iSeeCars.

This is the cheapest best-used truck under $10,000

An image of a Chevrolet Colorado parked indoors.
Chevrolet Colorado | STAN HONDA/AFP via Getty Images

Finishing off this list of best used pickup trucks, we’ve got the cheapest entry on iSeeCars’ list. It’s the 2007 Chevrolet Colorado, and it’ll cost you $8,012 on average. While you won’t get the best towing rating in its class at 3,589 lb, this small truck is priced considerably lower than the aforementioned Frontier.

According to iSeeCars, 0.8 percent of these trucks will surpass 200,000 miles in their lifetime. Despite this low percentage, it was still enough to land the Colorado on iSeeCars’ list of top 10 trucks. However, if you want the longest-lasting option, the Toyota is likely the way to go.