The Best Gas Push Mowers According to Consumer Reports

When it comes to buying a gas push mower, you’ve got plenty of options to choose from. So many, in fact, that choosing the best gas push mower for your lawn care needs could leave you feeling overwhelmed. Fortunately, Consumer Reports has the inside scoop on the best gas push mowers. 

A lineup of red Toro lawn mowers, the Toro Timemaster 21199 is among the best gas push mowers
Toro lawn mowers. | Daniel Acker/Bloomberg

Choosing the best lawn mower type for small yards

RELATED: The Best Lawn Mower Features to Look For In Your Next Mower

There are several different types of lawn mowers worth considering these days. But if you’re shopping for the best type of lawn mower for your small yard? Consumer Reports recommends opting for a push lawn mower. Why is that?

“In a small yard you’re more likely to be turning around or navigating around obstacles more often,” explained Misha Kollontai, a senior test project leader who covers lawn mowers for Consumer Reports. “A walk-behind mower is more appropriate for such jobs than a tractor or riding mower. It’s easier to navigate.”

Consumer Reports’ picks for the best gas push mowers

RELATED: The Worst Push Lawn Mowers and What to Buy Instead

Fortunately, picking the best gas push mower for your small yard isn’t all that difficult. In fact, Consumer Reports has already done the heavy lifting and recently highlighted its picks for the best gas push mowers. At the top of its list is the 21-inch Honda HRN216PKA.

While the Honda HRN216PKA ($400) is among the priciest lawn mowers on Consumer Reports’ list, the organization found its mulching and bagging performance is Very Good. It’s also among the most reliable lawn mowers and earned an Excellent owner satisfaction rating.

Consumer Reports also highlighted the 21-inch Troy-Bilt TB 115 ($230) as one of the best gas push mowers. This gas push mower excels in tasks like side-discharging and handling. Consumer Reports also gave it a Very Good rating in terms of cutting evenness. And when it comes to reliability and owner satisfaction? This gas push mower earned high marks in both categories.

Honda dominates when it comes to the best self-propelled gas mowers

RELATED: Lawn Mower Maintenance You Probably Aren’t Doing But Should Be

Say you would prefer a gas self-propelled lawn mower instead. If that’s the case, Consumer Reports says these three push lawn mowers are among the best gas push mowers: the Honda HRX217K6HZA, the Honda HRN216VKA, and the Toro Personal Pace Recycler 21465. 

The Honda HRX217K6HZA ($870) is on the more expensive side. However, Consumer Reports gave it Excellent ratings for mulching, bagging, evenness, and handling. The Honda HRN216VKA, on the other hand, earned Excellent ratings in mulching, cutting evenness, and handling. Priced at $629, the Honda HRX217K6HZA is also considered a Consumer Reports’ Best Buy. 

As for the Toro Personal Pace Recycler 21465? This self-propelled gas mower will have you spending roughly $399. This particular mower earned Excellent ratings in side discharging, mulching, and cutting evenness. It also earned Very Good ratings in bagging and handling. The only downside to this push lawn mower is that it can be noisy.

This Toro lawn mower is the best wide-deck self-propelled mower

RELATED: 3 Best Riding Lawn Mowers Under $2,500

Last but certainly not least is the Toro Timemaster 21199, which Consumer Reports tapped as the best wide-deck self-propelled mower. This wide-deck self-propelled lawn mower boasts a 30-inch cutting deck which Consumer Reports says will have you cutting your grass in about two-thirds of the time it takes with a regular push mower.

That’s not the only reason Consumer Reports highlighted it as one of the best gas push mowers either. The Toro Timemaster 21199 also earned Excellent ratings in lawn care tasks like bagging and cutting evenness. It also earned Very Good ratings in side discharging, mulching, and handling. Consumer Reports added that it earned an Excellent owner satisfaction rating.

How to choose the best lawn mower for your lawn care needs

Buying a new lawn mower can be stressful. The good news is that it doesn’t have to be. In fact, with Consumer Reports’ picks for the best gas push mowers in hand, choosing the best lawn mower for your needs is a more manageable task.