Review: The Cadillac ATS-V Is an All-American Dream Car

wheel-to-wheel copy

2016 Cadillac ATS-V|Source: James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet
2016 Cadillac ATS-V|Source: James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet

It’s 6:30 on a Tuesday night in Soho, and I’m behind the wheel of a brand new Cadillac ATS-V. Why am I taking Cadillac’s sports car through stop-and-go traffic on some of New York’s oldest, roughest, and most unforgiving cobblestone streets? Because I’m searching for something, some kind of connection between car, place, and driver. The Japanese (especially Mazda) call it Jinba Ittai, or “unifying horse and rider.” Unfortunately, we Yanks don’t have a word for it, so I’ll just have to stick with “something.”

The car’s thermometer reads 93 degrees outside; if I was in the BMW 340i or Jaguar XF S I had the previous two weeks, it would have read 33 degrees – and that’s a jarring difference when your mind works in Fahrenheit. The difference is jarring between those cars and this one too, and coming off those Europeans puts me in the right frame of mind to pick the ATS-V apart. After all, these are two marques that Cadillac has been gunning for ever since it launched its ambitious comeback at the turn of this century. So is the American still an aspirational car, or can it finally stand up to the Olde World?

2016 Cadillac ATS-V|Source: James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet
2016 Cadillac ATS-V|Source: James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet

I’m in Soho to find out, because Cadillac is headquartered here now. And Cadillac is here because Soho is the art, fashion, design, and overall hip moneyed capital of the United States. And I can feel that coming up through the ATS-V’s firm suspension along with every bump, dip, and drop in the cobblestone streets. Looking across the microfiber suede, carbon fiber, and leather dash, and across its garish Velocity Red hood, I’m smitten; I wouldn’t want to be in any other car right now. It’s 93 godforsaken degrees outside, not 33, dammit, I’m driving through the cradle of American high culture, and I’m as convinced as ever that Cadillac has returned to its status as one of The Big Guns.


2016 Cadillac ATS-V|Source: James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet
2016 Cadillac ATS-V | James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet

The ATS-V attracted more attention than anything I’ve tested this year, and surprisingly, all of it was positive. Then again, if you ask someone between the ages of 8 and 80 to describe what a fast car looks like, you’d get this. What surprised me most was just how different the -V, and the stock two-door ATS — a handsome and tastefully-styled personal luxury coupe, really are. The difference reportedly adds up to about 2,000 unique parts on the -V, which shows the second you lay eyes on the thing.

With its bulging fenders, quad exhaust, aggressive front fascia (unique sheet metal from the A-pillars forward), and those prominent intakes on the hood, the ATS-V looks purposeful and mean. But more importantly, there’s an element of familiarity about it that (I’m assuming) resonates with people. M4s, and AMG C63s sit low, have big wheels and lots of intakes too, but this sonofabitch is our hometown hero; the world-beating performance coupe with the heart of a muscle car and a Cadillac crest on the hood. You may have never heard of it before, but as soon as you see an ATS-V, you know you want one. No matter how hard you try, that’s something you can’t engineer into a car.

Exterior Pros and Cons

2016 Cadillac ATS-V air intake|Source: James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet
2016 Cadillac ATS-V air intake | James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet

+ You can’t miss the ATS-V on the roads, and you don’t want to, either.

+ Aggressive aero and all that carbon fiber trim telegraph that this is a serious, no-holds-barred performance machine.

+ Sorry Corvette, Cadillac’s performance coupe might just be a little cooler than you.

– Even in a color other than “Velocity Red,” the ATS-V will never be a sleeper.

– That fancy carbon fiber splitter will give you heartburn every time you come up on a speed bump, pothole, or steep driveway.


2016 Cadillac ATS-V|Source: James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet
2016 Cadillac ATS-V | James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet

464 horsepower and 445 pound-feet of torque. The ATS-V backs up its looks and attitude with 464 ponies going to the rear wheels, while 464 pound-feet push you back into its leather and microfiber suede Recaros. You could say that it shares its 3.6 liter V6 with the base ATS, but at this point, the two mills share little more than basic architecture and displacement. The ATS-V benefits from two big turbos, a forged crank, titanium con rods, an upgraded valve train, an intercooler, oil cooler, and a heavy duty oil pump. In plain English, this engine was designed to handle track duty, but refined enough to live under the hood of a Cadillac.

It amounts to a car that’s 192 horses more powerful than a base ATS, while also beating the M3 by 39, and the M4 by 20. When you factor in torque, it bests the AMG C63 too. While a six-speed manual is available (with rev-matching and no-lift shift for quicker acceleration runs), our test car had the eight-speed automatic, which in true Cadillac fashion, allows you to put it in drive and just go. Or better yet, you can put it in manual mode and let that V6 howl as you run through the gears yourself via steering wheel paddles. You can probably guess which mode we liked more…

Powertrain Pros and Cons

+ No V8? No, and you won’t miss one either.

+ The 3.6 sounds great, and its power suits this car perfectly.

+ The eight-speed transmission is a gem, and fast-shifting manual mode keeps you from missing that third pedal too much.

– Good lord, this engine throws off a lot of heat.

– At 16 miles per gallon in the city and 20 on the highway, don’t expect the ATS-V to be thrifty (not that you would, of course).


2016 Cadillac ATS-V|Source: James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet
2016 Cadillac ATS-V | James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet

I’ve had a few people at Cadillac tell me that they have no interest in following the lead of their German and Japanese rivals, and in the ATS-V, that shows through beautifully. Fit-and-finish and quality are world-class, but the hand-stitched black leather, tan microfiber suede, carbon fiber, aluminum, and piano black trim are arranged in a way that’s bold, inviting, and interesting to look at. It feels familiar like an American car but is every bit as formidable – if not more so – as its rivals.

Unsurprisingly, the rear seats are cramped for adults, but up front, the Recaro racing seats are firm, supportive, and very comfortable. Everything from height to lumbar to bolster width is electronically adjustable, allowing you to find the right seating position for virtually every driving situation.

Up front, the digital/analog instrument panel will be familiar to anybody who’s driven a modern GM with a digital dash before, but even that adds to the ATS-V’s character. The gauges come alive in a graceful little dance when you start the car, and the numbers on the speedo, tach, and MID share an unashamedly loud, italic typeface that looks right at home here but would make a German engineer break out into a cold sweat.

The ATS-V’s thick-rimmed steering wheel looks purposeful and feels great, and its controls work so well with the CUE infotainment system that you rarely have to take your hands off the wheel to make adjustments to the stereo, among other things. Paired with the heads-up display, the ATS-V comes across as nothing less than a pure driver’s car, but since it’s a Cadillac, it’s impossible to forget that you’re swaddled in luxury too.

Interior Pros and Cons

2016 Cadillac ATS-V|Source: James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet
2016 Cadillac ATS-V | James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet

+ Contrasting materials and a bold design make the ATS-V’ cabin a breath of fresh air compared to most of its rivals.

+ Fully-adjustable Recaros are purposeful and incredibly comfortable.

+ Thick suede steering wheel means business, and easy-to-use controls minimize the need to take your hands off the wheel.

– Lack of a cover over the cup holders breaks up an otherwise clean, dynamic looking interior.

– Black leather and piano black and metal trim get mighty hot in the summer.

– The rear seats aren’t unusable like in a lot of sports cars, but they aren’t exactly roomy, either.

Tech and Safety

2016 Cadillac ATS-V|Source: James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet
2016 Cadillac ATS-V|Source: James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet

The ATS-V owes a lot of its clean dash layout to Cadillac’s CUE infotainment system, which works beautifully here. Controls for the radio, HVAC, and infotainment system are handled by the piano black center dash console and eight-inch touchscreen. Press down on a setting, and the panel (or screen) gives your finger a reassuring bump as it adjusts, letting you know that it’s on the job. CUE has long been one of the more polarizing systems on the market, but it finally feels like its come into its own, and the aforementioned steering wheel controls do a lot to keep everything easy to use in any driving situation. A backup camera, front and rear parking assist, auto-dimming mirrors, wireless phone charging, and fantastic Bose stereo also work to make this performance car feel first and foremost like a Cadillac.

And even without the CUE and the other goodies, the -V still feels like a technological powerhouse, with most of its brainpower devoted to keeping it as fast, and as safe, as possible. An array of traction and stability controls work to make sure you don’t do something too stupid behind the wheel, an electronic limited-slip differential keeps all that power from overwhelming the rear wheels, massive Brembo brakes (six pistons up front, four rear) stop the car on a dime.

Tech and Safety Pros and Cons

Even though it was auto-dimming, we loved the old-school look of the ATS-V's mirror.| Source: James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet
Even though it was auto-dimming, we loved the old-school look of the ATS-V’s mirror. | James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet

+ CUE used to be cumbersome. It isn’t anymore.

+ As powerful as the ATS-V is, we don’t mind the electronic nannies. In fact, they do an excellent job of staying out of your way.

+ Between the eight-inch touchscreen and 5.7 inch MID between the analog/digital gauges, the driver gets a lot of information in a simple, easy-to-read package.

– Brembos are big, impressive, and strong enough to stop a freight train, but they can get a little grabby in traffic.

– The ATS-V feels like a technological tour de force; for some drivers, that may take some getting used to.

The Drive

2016 Cadillac ATS-V|Source: James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet
2016 Cadillac ATS-V | James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet

I couldn’t bear to keep the ATS-V in the city too long, so I took it on a long drive out to western New York to visit my family for a few days. It’s prime GM country where I’m from; home of the Rochester carburetor, EV research labs, and big Delco and Delphi plants that dot the landscape. About 70 miles from my hometown lies the Tonawanda Engine Plant, where the ’69 Corvette’s ZL1’s engine was built almost a half-century ago.

But I don’t think that that was the reason why so many people (and myself) responded to the ATS-V like they did. It feels built for New York state’s winding, two-lane highways, and straight, rolling routes through farm country. It stayed firmly planted through hairpins and switchbacks and keeps pulling as long as you’re on the go pedal. It looks like a surgical tool; clean, razor-sharp, and demanding respect. And while it stands out from the competition, it also stands apart from other hot GM offerings like Corvettes and Camaros. The ATS-V is a rare, special car, and it everything it does conveys that. Plus, my test car was loud and red. People love loud red cars.


2016 Cadillac ATS-V|Source: James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet
2016 Cadillac ATS-V | James Derek Sapienza/Autos Cheat Sheet

I pulled off 81 to get gas and a Coke about 40 miles south of Syracuse. It was one of those shops about three miles off the highway, surrounded by pine forest and not much else, with a single streetlight as the only landmark between the place and the on-ramp. It was around 11:30 at night and the heat hadn’t broken. The station was empty, and you could see the attendant trying to stay busy by mopping the floor.

I walked in, and the kid, about 18, swimming in his oversized work shirt and big glasses is staring out the window now, but he doesn’t say anything until I’m about six paces behind him.

“Hey, mister! Um, mister?”

(… mister? am I old enough to be a mister?)


“Izzat your Caddy?”

“Kind of. It’s Cadillac’s Caddy. I’m just a journalist they let drive it.”

“Shit. That’s the most beautiful car I’ve ever seen! Trade you for it?”

“What’ve ya got?”

“Honda Civic. Coupe. 2012. No rust [that’s a big selling point in these parts]. How ’bout it?”

“Sorry kid. I’d love to, but I don’t think Cadillac would be too happy with me.”

“Shit. Yeah, okay. Wow, beautiful car, mister. Most beautiful one I’ve ever seen. I’m gonna have one just like that someday.”

“Hope you do, kid. Good luck.”

I pay up, walk out, and face to the ATS-V head on. It looks good from this angle. On the downward grade to the pump, it looks even lower and meaner than it is. And what just happened to me has never happened before. And it’s not 1956, and I’m not Elvis, but some kid in an upstate farm town is out there lusting after a Cadillac, saw one, and it made his night. I pull away in manual mode, stomp the gas, and let the 3.6 rev real high and real loud through the gears, just so this kid knows what he’s going to have someday.

I could list the facts and figures again; the 464 ponies, the 4.2-second zero to 60 time, all the tech, the cushy interior, and whatever else, but for the life of me, I couldn’t sum the ATS-V up better than that minute-long exchange upstate. So for all the talk of whether or not Cadillac can compete with the Germans, British, or Japanese, it can. The ATS-V has that something; it’s a star. It does precision performance without being cold or clinical, gets attention without being too ostentatious, and feels every bit as substantial as its $78,905 price tag (base is $62,665). In short, Cadillac has built itself a world-class dream car. We’d like to have one in our garage someday too.

Like classics? It’s always Throwback Thursday somewhere.