According to Consumer Reports, These Are the Worst Push Mowers

The two most popular types of mowers are lawn tractors and walk-behind units. Which one you choose will generally depend on your yard size. A push lawn mower works best for smaller yards, but which model should you choose? Consumer Reports lists which ones they felt were the worst and why. Let’s look at the ones they didn’t like. 

Does it matter which push mowers you choose to buy?

A man with a push mower in an ally way.
Push mower | Getty Images

Choosing a lawn mower takes a lot of thought and research. You need to determine what tasks the mower will perform in your yard, how large the lawn is, and are there any obstacles to maneuver around. Buying one that isn’t right for your yard could cost you quite a bit of money in the long run. 

Walk-behind mowers come in either corded, battery-operated, or gas-powered. If you want to go high-tech, there are also robot ones that do the mowing for you. 

Electric mowers offer the advantage of not worrying about fuel, oil, or the usual maintenance that a gasoline-powered one has. They’re also quieter than a gas mower, which draws many people to them. 

However, gas-powered walk-behind lawn mowers are easier because they allow you to mow an entire yard without dealing with a cord that isn’t long enough or having a battery run out of charge in the middle of cutting the grass. 

Which push mowers did Consumer Reports dub the worst to pick for 2022?

Consumer Reports have three models on their worst picks list this year. First, there’s the Murray 152506, which actually handled quite well and cut the grass evenly. Unfortunately, its mulching and bagging tasks were just OK. Predicted reliability and owner satisfaction scores were fair as well. 

According to Consumer Reports, there’s the Worx WG779, which you can get for approximately $263 to $360. This battery-operated model didn’t impress the reviewers at all. Its performance was fair, but nothing made it stand out among its rivals. 

Lastly, there’s the Sun Joe MJ401C-XR, which is a battery push mower. It didn’t perform well in any of its tests. They gave it an overall score of 39 and recommended overlooking this model and finding something better. 

How do Consumer Reports perform their testing?


The Worst Push Lawn Mowers and What to Buy Instead

Consumer Reports uses a 500,000-square-foot field in Fort Myers, FL, to develop the best picks for lawn mowers. They begin evaluating models in late winter and test each unit in three modes, including mulching, bagging, and side-discharging. They also will try out any special features the machine claims to have. 

They use 1,800 lbs of grass seed, specifically rye, as it’s the more dense grass, and they plant it in different types of terrains, like level ground, ditches, and slopes. This way, they can test each machine on various types of land to see how well they handle each one. 

The team adds up their ratings to come up with the overall score. It includes predicted reliability scores and owner satisfaction data from their surveys. They will then release a list of each category’s best and worst models. 

Getting the wrong type of mower for your yard can waste money, so finding one that suits your needs is essential. Consumer Reports helps you narrow down your search by testing out models and letting you know which ones perform well and which ones don’t.