Skip to main content

If you have been shopping for a new or used car this year, then there’s a good chance that you have noticed significant price hike for used cars. You can blame the global chip shortage for that since there are fewer new cars to go around and the demand for used cars has skyrocketed. Some used cars in the market have even surpassed their original prices of when they were new.

ISeeCars recently conducted a study that shows 15 different vehicles that carry elevated prices on the used car market. As such, here are five most notable sedans and two SUVs from that list that cost more used than when they were new.

Five notable sedans with astronomical used car prices

1. Dodge Charger – $42,375 (Used), $38,587 (New)

2022 Dodge Charger SRT Hellcat Redeye: The most powerful and fastest mass-produced sedan in the world with 797-horsepower shown here in Smoke Show with the Satin Black Hood, Roof and Decklid
2022 Dodge Charger SRT Hellcat Redeye | Dodge

If you’re looking for a family sedan with more muscle than a Honda Accord or Toyota Camry, then the Dodge Charger is a great choice. With four different engines to choose from, including a 707-hp supercharged V8, there’s no denying that the Charger can get you and your family to your destination with speed and style.

For now, that speed will come at a price as the average price for a Dodge Charger is $42,375 on the used market, which is 9.8% more than its original new price of $42,375.

2. Honda Civic Sedan – $25,499 (Used), $24,223 (New)

Honda Civic Touring driving on the road
Honda Civic Touring driving on the road | Honda

Those looking for a compact sedan will naturally gravitate toward the venerable Honda Civic. And why not? It’s fuel-efficient, reliable, and best of all, it’s cheap. Not anymore. The average price of a used Civic is currently around $25,499, which is 5.3% higher than its new sticker price of $24,223.

3. Toyota Corolla – $24,776 (Used), $23,677 (New)

2022 Toyota Corolla | Joe Santos
2022 Toyota Corolla | Joe Santos, MotorBiscuit

If the Honda Civic sounds too pricey for you, then you can surely find a Toyota Corolla for a reasonable price, right? Wrong. ISeeCars reported that the average price for a used Corolla is $24,776, which is 4.6% higher than its original MSRP of $23,677. It looks like practicality and fuel efficiency now come at a much higher cost.

4. Subaru WRX – $36,029 (Used), $34,166 (New)

Subaru WRX | Subaru
Subaru WRX | Subaru

There’s nothing like driving a practical sedan with a 268-hp, turbocharged engine and an all-wheel-drivetrain. That’s the kind of fun that you would get out of a Subaru WRX, although that capability comes at a price. ISeeCars reports that a used WRX will set you back around $36,029, which is 5.5% more than what it cost when it was new.

5. Tesla Model 3 – $54,215 (Used), $49,652 (New)

Passenger's side front angle view of white 2022 Tesla Model 3, which has a long driving range
2022 Tesla Model 3 | Tesla

You would think that an electric car like the Tesla Model 3 would surely cost less on the used market, considering there are some tax credits available on the new model. However, it’s 2021, so that’s not the case. A used Model 3 currently costs an average of $54,215, which is a whopping 9.2% more than its new car price.

Here are a couple of SUV standouts from the list

1.Kia Telluride — $50,295 (Used), $46,429 (New)

A light gray 2022 Kia Telluride Nightfall Edition.
2022 Kia Telluride Nightfall | Kia

What can we say about the Kia Telluride that hasn’t already been said? Not much, other than it’s no surprise that there’s a price hike associated it. Although it’s too bad that the price hike has to do with the fact that it costs around $50,295 for a used model, which is 8.3% more than when it was new.

2. Tesla Model Y – $64,930 (Used), $56,685 (New)

White Tesla Model Y parked at a lake with a red surfboard on top. Tesla has increased the price of the Model Y and it could be because of new EV tax credits
Tesla Model Y | Tesla Motors

The Tesla Model Y has been a hot seller in the past year or so. However, we wouldn’t be surprised if the sales of used models slow down in the next year as the Model Y takes the cake for having the highest used car price compared to when it was new. ISeeCars reports that a Model Y currently sits at around $64,930 on the used market, which is a jaw-dropping 14.5% more than what it cost when it was new.

Used sedans and SUVs now come at a high price

Gone are the days of buying a used vehicle to save some money over buying a new one. The aforementioned sedans and SUVs aren’t the only vehicles to fall victim to the ever-changing market. If you would like to check out the other vehicles including the ISeeCars list, here is the list:

The list of used cars that cost more than when they were new.
The list of used cars that cost more than when they were new. |

How To Get A Great Used Car Price During The Shortage