5 Best Midsize SUVs, According to Consumer Reports

SUVs and crossovers are some of the most popular cars today, and it’s easy to see why. With drivers wanting additional room, function, and economy, midsize SUVs offer everything you need. But how do you know which one is the most reliable with the right features to suit your needs?

Fortunately, Consumers Reports works to compile crucial information about every new vehicle, giving you the best in ratings and reliability. Combining scores for owner satisfaction, road tests, safety, and reliability, here are their top five picks for the best midsize SUVs of 2019.

5. 2019 Ford Edge

The Ford Edge rounds out the top-five list of best midsize SUVs, with Consumer Reports giving it an overall rating score of 78. Starting at just under $30,000, the new Ford Edge offers plenty of space at an affordable price. Well-rounded and reliable, it’s known for its handling and easy ride.

Consumer Reports’ road test gave it an impressive score of 84, with an overall fuel rating of 22 MPG. The new Ford Edge earned high ratings for acceleration, handling, and exceptional braking power. It also received high marks for its comfort, climate system, and standard safety features.

4. 2019 Hyundai Santa Fe/XL


Consumer Reports ranked the new Santa Fe slightly above the Ford Edge with an overall score of 80. But its upgraded version, the XL, received a higher rating of 81. The base Santa Fe starts around $25,000, while the XL starts at $30,000. Both midsize SUVs shared high marks for comfort, handling, control, safety features, and rear-seat access.

According to U.S. News, the base Santa Fe comes with a reliable 2.4-liter, four-cylinder engine, while the XL gets an upgraded six-cylinder. Upgrading to the XL will land you impressive third-row seating unlike any in its class. The Santa Fe delivers lots of power and space, as well as a quiet, safe ride.

3. 2019 Toyota Highlander

With an impressive overall score of 85, the Highlander is built with the reliability we’ve come to expect from Toyota. According to Consumer Reports, the Toyota Highlander is a pleasant surprise on the road, scoring an 82/100 on the road test. It comes with a multitude of standard advanced safety features, great gas mileage, and an accommodating interior with third-row seating.

The Highlander starts at just over $30,000, but it’s known for its high resale value. You’ll also find variety with the Highlander line. There are three transmission choices, two engines, and even a hybrid option.

2. 2020 Kia Telluride

The brand new Kia Telluride is faster than most SUVs, hitting 60 miles per hour in 7.2 seconds. An already impressive overall score of 90, combined with a road test score of 97, makes the Telluride an obvious contender on the list.

Starting at just over $30,000, the Kia Telluride offers many features and impressive performance at an affordable price. The Telluride received its best scores in braking power, transmission, and comfort, as well as noise reduction and quality of ride. According to Kia, the Telluride boasts “impressive handling and power, advanced technology, and the most interior passenger room in its segment.” 

1. 2019 Subaru Ascent

Topping the list of Consumer Reports’ best-midsize SUVs is the 2019 Subaru Ascent. This car received a near-perfect overall score of 96, with higher scores in reliability and owner satisfaction than any other new midsize SUV.

According to Consumer Reports, the Ascent comes with superior braking power, transmission, ride comfort, and engine performance. Drivers find the Subaru Ascent comfortable, easy, and fun to drive. The quiet cabin comes with third-row seating, as well as advanced tech and safety features. What’s even more impressive is that the smooth, quick Ascent starts at just over $30,000.