Skip to main content

In the 2000s, the pickup truck segment significantly increased in popularity. During this time, pickup trucks built upon their traditional functionality to offer greater comfort and premium amenities. This made them a better option for a daily driver vehicle. There are some great trucks from the 2000s. However, there are also some unreliable ones that prone to breaking down. Here are the three most unreliable used 2000s pickup trucks that you should avoid.

Avoid an unreliable used Chevy Silverado from the 2000s

Side view of silver 2007 Chevy Silverado, an unreliable used 2000s pickup truck to avoid
2007 Chevy Silverado | Chevrolet

The first unreliable used 2000s pickup truck that you should avoid is the Chevy Silverado. The Silverado has many positive attributes, such as its powerful engine options, towing prowess, and high-level utility. However, its reliability issues make the Silverado a bad option for buying used. The cost and hassle of often having to get replacement parts and repairs are not worth it.

A common problem for a used 2000s Silverado is rusted brake lines. Also, 2005-2006 Silverado models have a problem with the steering wheel. They have a “clunking noise that is all too common for Chevrolet trucks.” Another problem for the Silverado is oil and fuel consumption. As detailed by HotCars, “some owners complained about having to use 2 quarts of oil after just 1,000 miles.”

2004-2005 GMC Envoy XUV is an unreliable used pickup truck you should avoid

The second unreliable used 2000s pickup truck that you should avoid is the GMC Envoy XUV. Few people probably know about the Envoy XUV, for GM sold it for only two model years (2004-2005). 

Originally, the automaker had high hopes for the Envoy EUV as a “pickup-SUV combo,” with targeted sales of 30,000 units per year. However, it “never even managed to reach a third of it.” The Envoy XUV was plagued by quality issues, and it was discontinued after only two years on the market. There are rumors that GM will revive the Envoy nameplate, but it’s doubtful that there will be a high demand for it. 

The unreliable 2005-2009 Nissan Frontier is a bad choice for a used pickup truck

Front angle view of beige 2005 Nissan Frontier, an unreliable used 2000s pickup truck to avoid
2005 Nissan Frontier | Nissan

The third unreliable used 2000s pickup truck that you should avoid is the 2005-2009 Nissan Frontier. While the first-generation Frontier made big waves when it debuted in 1997, the second-generation Frontier, which debuted in 2005, has transmission issues. This issue affected other pickup truck manufacturers, but it is especially problematic for the Frontier. 

A design flaw with the radiator is the primary cause of the transmission problems. The flaw makes the “radiator more susceptible to cracking when under pressure.” Buying a used Frontier from the mid-to-late 2000s means that you’ll likely have to “change the transmission from time to time.”

In addition to the Chevy Silverado, GMC Envoy XUV, and Nissan Frontier, HotCars lists some other unreliable used pickup trucks from the 2000s. This includes the Subaru Baja, Ford F-250, Chevrolet Colorado, Chevrolet Avalanche, Dodge Dakota, Dodge Ram Daytona, Hummer H2 SUT, Mitsubishi L200, and Lincoln Blackwood. Unless you’re ok with the cost and inconvenience of frequent repairs, it’s best to avoid these used pickup trucks.

Best in Trucks & SUVs
Staff Writer, Producer - SUVs

Mark Putzer

With seven years of experience writing in the automotive industry prior to joining MotorBiscuit in 2021, Mark’s work can be found on dealership websites across North America. A Bachelor of Science degree in zoology from the University of Wisconsin-Madison sent Mark into the wilderness for environmental studies. Here, he discovered a passion for driving off-road trucks and SUVs off the beaten path.

During his extensive international travels, Mark developed an affinity for foreign cars and international automotive markets. Inspired by the industry-wide push toward environmentally-friendly EVs and hybrids, Mark covers topics about recent advances in the automotive industry, in addition to everything from off-road concepts to emerging EV technology.